The First Book Crush

Susan here – recently we Wenches were talking about heroes, particularly the first fictional heroes we encountered early on that made our juvenile writer's hearts go pitty-pat. Who were our first book crushes? Which heroes did we want to take away from the book and keep around forever? Those questions led us to wondering how those fictional heroes helped form our earliest ideas of what a hero truly is. Did these early crushes work their way into our novels? Certainly they influenced the heroes we would write later in our novels.

Here’s what the Wenches had to say about their very first book crushes:

Jo Beverley:

Scarlet-pimpernel-baroness-emmuska-orczy-paperback-cover-artPerhaps Robin Hood in the Carola Oman book, but truly it has to be The ScarletPimpernel. I think I was about ten when I plunged into it, and though it's what we'd now call "sweet," it's packed with drama and passion. Unlike many, I don't swoon for rough diamonds. I go for smooth and elegant heroes, so Sir Percy Blakeney, for all his foppishness, appealed. Add in his brave adventurous exploits and his natural leadership of his equals and he was my sort of guy, even when young. We see a similar pattern in Francis Crawford of Lymond from the Dorothy Dunnett books — supremely elegant and gifted, devious, brave and resourceful, and probably my ultimate hero — but I discovered him much later. I sometimes wonder what effect The Game of Kings would have had on me if I'd read it on first publication in 1961 instead of ten years later!

As it was, both heroes came into the mix when I wrote my first book, which eventually became An Arranged Marriage. I'm sure someone could write a thesis on writer psychology based on our first heroes and heroines, but they'd have to peel back some layers, as An Arranged Marriage was my sixth published book.  

Patricia Rice:

PandPI am so terribly clichéd! My first swoon-worthy book hero was Darcy from Pride and Prejudice. You have to understand that I was only nine and had never read a romance book, so perhaps I can be excused. I promptly followed P & P with Jane Eyre and utterly adored the indomitable Jane but never fell in love with Rochester. I liked the brooding dark looks but thought he was an inexcusable jerk.

And like Jo, I have to wonder about the psychology of our choices. I have always preferred beta heroes to alphas. While I loved Percy in The Scarlet Pimpernel, I preferred rougher guys like the cowboys in Zane Grey (or James Garner in Maverick, if we can veer from books!).  Darcy may have been elegant, but socially, he had this appealing introversion happening that worked for a bookworm like me.

I wonder what it is inside us that chooses our heroes?

Joanna Bourne:

Kim-kipling
I loved Rudyard Kipling's Kim. He was a boy in the book and I wasn't any older when I first read him. Does it count as a bookcrush if you're both twelve? I think SO. I loved Kim's cheerful courage. Loved the way he slipped through the exotic world of India, blending into the crowds, playing many roles, clear-eyed, cheeky, resilient. So wise for his age — for any age, really. Loved the way he became a Mbwillie holdaway2
spy. Loved the way he traveled from one life to another.

Who else?  Willie Garvin. He's the sidekick and male protagonist of Peter O'Donnel's Modesty Blaise series. Massive, muscled and strong, blond, the imperturbable, Cockney-speaking expert with a throwing knife. 

And JimGrim from Talbot Mundy. He's another tough, fiercely competent, adamantly principled adventurer. He leads a band of like-minded men and women on adventures through exotic lands.

I think I'm giving away a bit about where my writing comes from …

Nicola Cornick:

Eagle9thI can't remember which hero was my very first book crush but an early one was Marcus Flavius Aquila from Rosemary Sutcliff's The Eagle of the Ninth. I must have been about thirteen years old. I fell in love with the whole book, with the history and the adventure and the way in which Rosemary Sutcliff created such a vivid picture of Roman Britain. Marcus was quite young in the story, in his early twenties, I think, but he had been a soldier and been injured and it felt as though his experiences had give him an edge. He was resourceful and courageous and I totally identified with his determination to restore the honour his family had lost when his father's legion had disappeared without a trace. I think the book and Marcus' character were very influential on me as a writer. I love the idea of a strong hero who rights wrongs and I also enjoy reading and writing the self-contained loner type of hero who discovers that developing emotional bonds with others can be hugely rewarding.

Anne Gracie:

DevilscubI loved some of the heroes other have mentioned, too — I thought the Scarlet Pimpernel was wonderful, but I hated the way Marguerite treated him and the meek way he took it so he was never a crush. I loved Marcus from Eagle of the Ninth, too, but I read him when I was twelve and was already taken by then. *g* Because when I was eleven I discovered Heyer and had fallen head over heels in love with Damerel. First it was Vidal (Devil's Cub) who was underneath all the bad Venetia
behavior, honorable and and then it was Damerel (Venetia) another bad-boy with a self-destructive streak of honor, and a wonderful sense of humor, and then it was Hugo (The Unknown Ajax) who was big and quietly self-confident and who had the wickedest sense of humor. And then it was Damerel again, because, well, he's Damerel. 

My crush on Heyeroes has remained strong, even though I'm very susceptible to other book hero crushes, and I know they have influenced me hugely in my choice of heroes in my own writing. I say "choice" but it never feels like I "choose" — the heroes mostly just arrive on the page, and I have to deal with them. Though I'm not complaining — getting to know a hero is always fun. And a sense of humor, or at least the ability to see the ridiculous in life, is often a feature, as well as a deep streak of honor.

Cara Elliott/Andrea Pickens:

This rough magicI dragged my pen in responding to this question, which was delightful in one sense because I had a sneak preview of all the other Wenchly responses, and got to smile and swoon over the reminders of wonderful “first love” heroes. Like Pat, I fell early and hard for Mr. Darcy, like Jo, I adored Percy, and like Anne I had serial crushes on a number Heyer’s heroes. But the down side was—all those marvelous men were already taken, so I needed to come up with yet another swoon-worthy man. (Yes, I know—it’s hard work, thinking about heroes!) Well, that didn’t take long . . . in my early teens I discovered Mary Stewart, and Max Gale, the hero in This Rough Magic, quickly had my heart doing little flop-flops. Handsome, moody, impossibly arrogant . . . like Lucy, I was annoyed yet fascinated by him and vicariously enjoyed crossed verbal swords with him, determined to win his regard. That he was fiercely kind and loyal beneath his prickly reserve, and a tough, capable hero as well as a sensitive artist had me heaving fluttery sighs for years. 

Susan King:

Moonspinners movie RobinhoodMy earliest hero crushes were Superman and Robin Hood — the Superman of the comics, with his dazzling blue eyes and black hair, his muscled strength and his vulnerable side. I read every Robin Hood tale I could find — his loyalty, sense of honor, rebellious courage and sense of humor probably influenced the medieval novels I would later write. When I read Little Women, I adored, as Jo March did, Professor Bhaer—gruff, unkempt, shy, a quiet bull of a man who was intelligent and so kind.

And then, like Andrea, I discovered Mary Stewart. My crush on Mark Langley in The Moonspinners had staying power. The movie helped, I must say—my adolescent heart fell with a thud for Peter McEnery’s Mark—but Stewart’s Mark added more layers to the developing profile of my favorite hero—intelligent, kind, naturally sexy, complicated but understated, and capable of stepping back to let the heroine fend for herself. Blend Mark Langley with Robin Hood, add a touch of Superman and Professor Bhaer, and those components are found in some of the heroes I've written–quiet but powerful, loyal yet rebellious, complex, wry, kind, and often with deep, dark secrets.  

Tell us about your first book crush – what appealed to you then, and have you searched for him in every book since?

Susan

 

320 thoughts on “The First Book Crush”

  1. It was de Coucy in The Lady Royal by Molly Costain Haycraft. On re-reading it, I’m not so impressed, but at the time it seemed wonderful how he wooed her time and again after abusing her (a rough, angry kiss) because he thought she broken a man’s heart. Plus it was a hard cover book from the library, and from there I begged my mother for more romances. I kind of miss the hero who falls in love and then spends a lot of time trying to win the lady’s heart.
    Strangely enough, I am reading something like that now; it’s hard going because the heroine had her life shattered during her first season. The author gets all the details of her reactions right.

    Reply
  2. It was de Coucy in The Lady Royal by Molly Costain Haycraft. On re-reading it, I’m not so impressed, but at the time it seemed wonderful how he wooed her time and again after abusing her (a rough, angry kiss) because he thought she broken a man’s heart. Plus it was a hard cover book from the library, and from there I begged my mother for more romances. I kind of miss the hero who falls in love and then spends a lot of time trying to win the lady’s heart.
    Strangely enough, I am reading something like that now; it’s hard going because the heroine had her life shattered during her first season. The author gets all the details of her reactions right.

    Reply
  3. It was de Coucy in The Lady Royal by Molly Costain Haycraft. On re-reading it, I’m not so impressed, but at the time it seemed wonderful how he wooed her time and again after abusing her (a rough, angry kiss) because he thought she broken a man’s heart. Plus it was a hard cover book from the library, and from there I begged my mother for more romances. I kind of miss the hero who falls in love and then spends a lot of time trying to win the lady’s heart.
    Strangely enough, I am reading something like that now; it’s hard going because the heroine had her life shattered during her first season. The author gets all the details of her reactions right.

    Reply
  4. It was de Coucy in The Lady Royal by Molly Costain Haycraft. On re-reading it, I’m not so impressed, but at the time it seemed wonderful how he wooed her time and again after abusing her (a rough, angry kiss) because he thought she broken a man’s heart. Plus it was a hard cover book from the library, and from there I begged my mother for more romances. I kind of miss the hero who falls in love and then spends a lot of time trying to win the lady’s heart.
    Strangely enough, I am reading something like that now; it’s hard going because the heroine had her life shattered during her first season. The author gets all the details of her reactions right.

    Reply
  5. It was de Coucy in The Lady Royal by Molly Costain Haycraft. On re-reading it, I’m not so impressed, but at the time it seemed wonderful how he wooed her time and again after abusing her (a rough, angry kiss) because he thought she broken a man’s heart. Plus it was a hard cover book from the library, and from there I begged my mother for more romances. I kind of miss the hero who falls in love and then spends a lot of time trying to win the lady’s heart.
    Strangely enough, I am reading something like that now; it’s hard going because the heroine had her life shattered during her first season. The author gets all the details of her reactions right.

    Reply
  6. Alan Breck Stewart, in Stevenson’s Kidnapped. It’s not a romance, obviously, but combined with innumerable Sir Walter Scott tales, it made me a confirmed Jacobite. Which is odd, since during the French Revolution, I’m pretty sure I’d have been a Jacobin. I’m not sure if I have a weakness for hopeless causes or just for the letter J.

    Reply
  7. Alan Breck Stewart, in Stevenson’s Kidnapped. It’s not a romance, obviously, but combined with innumerable Sir Walter Scott tales, it made me a confirmed Jacobite. Which is odd, since during the French Revolution, I’m pretty sure I’d have been a Jacobin. I’m not sure if I have a weakness for hopeless causes or just for the letter J.

    Reply
  8. Alan Breck Stewart, in Stevenson’s Kidnapped. It’s not a romance, obviously, but combined with innumerable Sir Walter Scott tales, it made me a confirmed Jacobite. Which is odd, since during the French Revolution, I’m pretty sure I’d have been a Jacobin. I’m not sure if I have a weakness for hopeless causes or just for the letter J.

    Reply
  9. Alan Breck Stewart, in Stevenson’s Kidnapped. It’s not a romance, obviously, but combined with innumerable Sir Walter Scott tales, it made me a confirmed Jacobite. Which is odd, since during the French Revolution, I’m pretty sure I’d have been a Jacobin. I’m not sure if I have a weakness for hopeless causes or just for the letter J.

    Reply
  10. Alan Breck Stewart, in Stevenson’s Kidnapped. It’s not a romance, obviously, but combined with innumerable Sir Walter Scott tales, it made me a confirmed Jacobite. Which is odd, since during the French Revolution, I’m pretty sure I’d have been a Jacobin. I’m not sure if I have a weakness for hopeless causes or just for the letter J.

    Reply
  11. I apparently have a weakness for pirates, although I don’t use them in my novels, not even when I was writing historical romance back in the 90s. Two stand out and I’m not sure which came first. One is Kit Gerado in Frank Yerby’s The Golden Hawk. The other is the hero of Daphne de Maurier’s Frenchman’s Creek. Did he even have an name? Lymond came later. And if we’re including the Sunday comics, I’ll add Brenda Starr’s mystery man with the eyepatch and the orchids.
    Kathy/Kaitlyn

    Reply
  12. I apparently have a weakness for pirates, although I don’t use them in my novels, not even when I was writing historical romance back in the 90s. Two stand out and I’m not sure which came first. One is Kit Gerado in Frank Yerby’s The Golden Hawk. The other is the hero of Daphne de Maurier’s Frenchman’s Creek. Did he even have an name? Lymond came later. And if we’re including the Sunday comics, I’ll add Brenda Starr’s mystery man with the eyepatch and the orchids.
    Kathy/Kaitlyn

    Reply
  13. I apparently have a weakness for pirates, although I don’t use them in my novels, not even when I was writing historical romance back in the 90s. Two stand out and I’m not sure which came first. One is Kit Gerado in Frank Yerby’s The Golden Hawk. The other is the hero of Daphne de Maurier’s Frenchman’s Creek. Did he even have an name? Lymond came later. And if we’re including the Sunday comics, I’ll add Brenda Starr’s mystery man with the eyepatch and the orchids.
    Kathy/Kaitlyn

    Reply
  14. I apparently have a weakness for pirates, although I don’t use them in my novels, not even when I was writing historical romance back in the 90s. Two stand out and I’m not sure which came first. One is Kit Gerado in Frank Yerby’s The Golden Hawk. The other is the hero of Daphne de Maurier’s Frenchman’s Creek. Did he even have an name? Lymond came later. And if we’re including the Sunday comics, I’ll add Brenda Starr’s mystery man with the eyepatch and the orchids.
    Kathy/Kaitlyn

    Reply
  15. I apparently have a weakness for pirates, although I don’t use them in my novels, not even when I was writing historical romance back in the 90s. Two stand out and I’m not sure which came first. One is Kit Gerado in Frank Yerby’s The Golden Hawk. The other is the hero of Daphne de Maurier’s Frenchman’s Creek. Did he even have an name? Lymond came later. And if we’re including the Sunday comics, I’ll add Brenda Starr’s mystery man with the eyepatch and the orchids.
    Kathy/Kaitlyn

    Reply
  16. LOL on the J, Lil! I fell in love with some Jacobites in my teens, but fell out of love later as I came to understand the political complexities. Was always on the side of the poor aristos in the French Revolution, and still would side with them, I think, because of the unleashing of terror and anarchy, which then led to a kind of dictatorship under Napoleon. That forms an element of my next book, in fact.

    Reply
  17. LOL on the J, Lil! I fell in love with some Jacobites in my teens, but fell out of love later as I came to understand the political complexities. Was always on the side of the poor aristos in the French Revolution, and still would side with them, I think, because of the unleashing of terror and anarchy, which then led to a kind of dictatorship under Napoleon. That forms an element of my next book, in fact.

    Reply
  18. LOL on the J, Lil! I fell in love with some Jacobites in my teens, but fell out of love later as I came to understand the political complexities. Was always on the side of the poor aristos in the French Revolution, and still would side with them, I think, because of the unleashing of terror and anarchy, which then led to a kind of dictatorship under Napoleon. That forms an element of my next book, in fact.

    Reply
  19. LOL on the J, Lil! I fell in love with some Jacobites in my teens, but fell out of love later as I came to understand the political complexities. Was always on the side of the poor aristos in the French Revolution, and still would side with them, I think, because of the unleashing of terror and anarchy, which then led to a kind of dictatorship under Napoleon. That forms an element of my next book, in fact.

    Reply
  20. LOL on the J, Lil! I fell in love with some Jacobites in my teens, but fell out of love later as I came to understand the political complexities. Was always on the side of the poor aristos in the French Revolution, and still would side with them, I think, because of the unleashing of terror and anarchy, which then led to a kind of dictatorship under Napoleon. That forms an element of my next book, in fact.

    Reply
  21. As a child I read a lot of books which dated from my mother’s childhood. I fell for David Morton in Malcolm Saville’s Lone Pine series, and Meryon in Monica Edwards’s Romney Marsh series. I’m still fond of them, especially Meryon.
    I also liked Heyer’s heroes, although I never cared for Vidal. And Mary Stewart’s heroes are also lovely, especially Raoul de Valmy in Nine Coaches waiting, and Richard Byron in Madam, Will You Talk?
    I also loved Josephine Tey’s books, and fell for Brat Farrar, perhaps an unlikely crush!

    Reply
  22. As a child I read a lot of books which dated from my mother’s childhood. I fell for David Morton in Malcolm Saville’s Lone Pine series, and Meryon in Monica Edwards’s Romney Marsh series. I’m still fond of them, especially Meryon.
    I also liked Heyer’s heroes, although I never cared for Vidal. And Mary Stewart’s heroes are also lovely, especially Raoul de Valmy in Nine Coaches waiting, and Richard Byron in Madam, Will You Talk?
    I also loved Josephine Tey’s books, and fell for Brat Farrar, perhaps an unlikely crush!

    Reply
  23. As a child I read a lot of books which dated from my mother’s childhood. I fell for David Morton in Malcolm Saville’s Lone Pine series, and Meryon in Monica Edwards’s Romney Marsh series. I’m still fond of them, especially Meryon.
    I also liked Heyer’s heroes, although I never cared for Vidal. And Mary Stewart’s heroes are also lovely, especially Raoul de Valmy in Nine Coaches waiting, and Richard Byron in Madam, Will You Talk?
    I also loved Josephine Tey’s books, and fell for Brat Farrar, perhaps an unlikely crush!

    Reply
  24. As a child I read a lot of books which dated from my mother’s childhood. I fell for David Morton in Malcolm Saville’s Lone Pine series, and Meryon in Monica Edwards’s Romney Marsh series. I’m still fond of them, especially Meryon.
    I also liked Heyer’s heroes, although I never cared for Vidal. And Mary Stewart’s heroes are also lovely, especially Raoul de Valmy in Nine Coaches waiting, and Richard Byron in Madam, Will You Talk?
    I also loved Josephine Tey’s books, and fell for Brat Farrar, perhaps an unlikely crush!

    Reply
  25. As a child I read a lot of books which dated from my mother’s childhood. I fell for David Morton in Malcolm Saville’s Lone Pine series, and Meryon in Monica Edwards’s Romney Marsh series. I’m still fond of them, especially Meryon.
    I also liked Heyer’s heroes, although I never cared for Vidal. And Mary Stewart’s heroes are also lovely, especially Raoul de Valmy in Nine Coaches waiting, and Richard Byron in Madam, Will You Talk?
    I also loved Josephine Tey’s books, and fell for Brat Farrar, perhaps an unlikely crush!

    Reply
  26. Oh yeah, almost all Mary Stewart’s heroes! I liked Brat Farrar too, which is interesting given that he was really an anti-hero, I suppose. I’m loving all these crushes people are owning up to!

    Reply
  27. Oh yeah, almost all Mary Stewart’s heroes! I liked Brat Farrar too, which is interesting given that he was really an anti-hero, I suppose. I’m loving all these crushes people are owning up to!

    Reply
  28. Oh yeah, almost all Mary Stewart’s heroes! I liked Brat Farrar too, which is interesting given that he was really an anti-hero, I suppose. I’m loving all these crushes people are owning up to!

    Reply
  29. Oh yeah, almost all Mary Stewart’s heroes! I liked Brat Farrar too, which is interesting given that he was really an anti-hero, I suppose. I’m loving all these crushes people are owning up to!

    Reply
  30. Oh yeah, almost all Mary Stewart’s heroes! I liked Brat Farrar too, which is interesting given that he was really an anti-hero, I suppose. I’m loving all these crushes people are owning up to!

    Reply
  31. Having written one of those books recently (Wicked Wyckerly), I know how hard it is to create a conflict that keeps the pages turning when one of the protagonists has already surrendered to love. 😉 But I do love a determined hero!

    Reply
  32. Having written one of those books recently (Wicked Wyckerly), I know how hard it is to create a conflict that keeps the pages turning when one of the protagonists has already surrendered to love. 😉 But I do love a determined hero!

    Reply
  33. Having written one of those books recently (Wicked Wyckerly), I know how hard it is to create a conflict that keeps the pages turning when one of the protagonists has already surrendered to love. 😉 But I do love a determined hero!

    Reply
  34. Having written one of those books recently (Wicked Wyckerly), I know how hard it is to create a conflict that keeps the pages turning when one of the protagonists has already surrendered to love. 😉 But I do love a determined hero!

    Reply
  35. Having written one of those books recently (Wicked Wyckerly), I know how hard it is to create a conflict that keeps the pages turning when one of the protagonists has already surrendered to love. 😉 But I do love a determined hero!

    Reply
  36. Can’t remember my first book crush but it was probably along the lines of Aragorn in The Lied of the Rings! Or someone from Andre Norton’s Witch World Series — I was very into fantasy those days. Then I discovered Jane Austen! Immediately head over heels for Mr. Darcy! I did compare real life boyfriends to Austen characters ever after. I married Mr. Knightley!

    Reply
  37. Can’t remember my first book crush but it was probably along the lines of Aragorn in The Lied of the Rings! Or someone from Andre Norton’s Witch World Series — I was very into fantasy those days. Then I discovered Jane Austen! Immediately head over heels for Mr. Darcy! I did compare real life boyfriends to Austen characters ever after. I married Mr. Knightley!

    Reply
  38. Can’t remember my first book crush but it was probably along the lines of Aragorn in The Lied of the Rings! Or someone from Andre Norton’s Witch World Series — I was very into fantasy those days. Then I discovered Jane Austen! Immediately head over heels for Mr. Darcy! I did compare real life boyfriends to Austen characters ever after. I married Mr. Knightley!

    Reply
  39. Can’t remember my first book crush but it was probably along the lines of Aragorn in The Lied of the Rings! Or someone from Andre Norton’s Witch World Series — I was very into fantasy those days. Then I discovered Jane Austen! Immediately head over heels for Mr. Darcy! I did compare real life boyfriends to Austen characters ever after. I married Mr. Knightley!

    Reply
  40. Can’t remember my first book crush but it was probably along the lines of Aragorn in The Lied of the Rings! Or someone from Andre Norton’s Witch World Series — I was very into fantasy those days. Then I discovered Jane Austen! Immediately head over heels for Mr. Darcy! I did compare real life boyfriends to Austen characters ever after. I married Mr. Knightley!

    Reply
  41. Actually, the first crush I remember was Francis Crawford. I liked Mary Stewart’s heroes, but didn’t swoon over them, but Lymond!
    A love affair that continues to this day, even when I want to whap him over the head.

    Reply
  42. Actually, the first crush I remember was Francis Crawford. I liked Mary Stewart’s heroes, but didn’t swoon over them, but Lymond!
    A love affair that continues to this day, even when I want to whap him over the head.

    Reply
  43. Actually, the first crush I remember was Francis Crawford. I liked Mary Stewart’s heroes, but didn’t swoon over them, but Lymond!
    A love affair that continues to this day, even when I want to whap him over the head.

    Reply
  44. Actually, the first crush I remember was Francis Crawford. I liked Mary Stewart’s heroes, but didn’t swoon over them, but Lymond!
    A love affair that continues to this day, even when I want to whap him over the head.

    Reply
  45. Actually, the first crush I remember was Francis Crawford. I liked Mary Stewart’s heroes, but didn’t swoon over them, but Lymond!
    A love affair that continues to this day, even when I want to whap him over the head.

    Reply
  46. Oh yes, to Brat Farrar. I can take a bit of duplicity in my heroes, as long as it’s not malicious. And Brat has some lovely moral struggles as a result. Josephine Tey has just been reprinted in the UK and her books story telling stands up excellently. And the Scarlet Pimpernel. And Damerel. Most Heyer heroes,in fact, including heavenly Freddy from Cotillion. Also Stewart.
    I was quite keen on Saville’s geeky Jon Warrender but my first true hero was Humphrey from Children of the New Forest. He was so much his own man, in spite of his elder brother being all glamorous cavalier all over the place. And I just loved how competent he was and how he turned himself into a real woodsman. Bliss.

    Reply
  47. Oh yes, to Brat Farrar. I can take a bit of duplicity in my heroes, as long as it’s not malicious. And Brat has some lovely moral struggles as a result. Josephine Tey has just been reprinted in the UK and her books story telling stands up excellently. And the Scarlet Pimpernel. And Damerel. Most Heyer heroes,in fact, including heavenly Freddy from Cotillion. Also Stewart.
    I was quite keen on Saville’s geeky Jon Warrender but my first true hero was Humphrey from Children of the New Forest. He was so much his own man, in spite of his elder brother being all glamorous cavalier all over the place. And I just loved how competent he was and how he turned himself into a real woodsman. Bliss.

    Reply
  48. Oh yes, to Brat Farrar. I can take a bit of duplicity in my heroes, as long as it’s not malicious. And Brat has some lovely moral struggles as a result. Josephine Tey has just been reprinted in the UK and her books story telling stands up excellently. And the Scarlet Pimpernel. And Damerel. Most Heyer heroes,in fact, including heavenly Freddy from Cotillion. Also Stewart.
    I was quite keen on Saville’s geeky Jon Warrender but my first true hero was Humphrey from Children of the New Forest. He was so much his own man, in spite of his elder brother being all glamorous cavalier all over the place. And I just loved how competent he was and how he turned himself into a real woodsman. Bliss.

    Reply
  49. Oh yes, to Brat Farrar. I can take a bit of duplicity in my heroes, as long as it’s not malicious. And Brat has some lovely moral struggles as a result. Josephine Tey has just been reprinted in the UK and her books story telling stands up excellently. And the Scarlet Pimpernel. And Damerel. Most Heyer heroes,in fact, including heavenly Freddy from Cotillion. Also Stewart.
    I was quite keen on Saville’s geeky Jon Warrender but my first true hero was Humphrey from Children of the New Forest. He was so much his own man, in spite of his elder brother being all glamorous cavalier all over the place. And I just loved how competent he was and how he turned himself into a real woodsman. Bliss.

    Reply
  50. Oh yes, to Brat Farrar. I can take a bit of duplicity in my heroes, as long as it’s not malicious. And Brat has some lovely moral struggles as a result. Josephine Tey has just been reprinted in the UK and her books story telling stands up excellently. And the Scarlet Pimpernel. And Damerel. Most Heyer heroes,in fact, including heavenly Freddy from Cotillion. Also Stewart.
    I was quite keen on Saville’s geeky Jon Warrender but my first true hero was Humphrey from Children of the New Forest. He was so much his own man, in spite of his elder brother being all glamorous cavalier all over the place. And I just loved how competent he was and how he turned himself into a real woodsman. Bliss.

    Reply
  51. Gilbert Blythe from Anne of Green Gables won my 10 year old heart. He was so persistent and faithful in light of Anne’s disinterest. I was so upset that Jo March inutile Women turned her nose up at Laurie, my second fictional crush (is he still a hero if he doesn’t get the girl he should?) and then, in grade 9, at 13, I met Mr. Darcy. Sigh. He was probably my first grown up book crush. But then, how could you not fall in love with Me. Darcy?

    Reply
  52. Gilbert Blythe from Anne of Green Gables won my 10 year old heart. He was so persistent and faithful in light of Anne’s disinterest. I was so upset that Jo March inutile Women turned her nose up at Laurie, my second fictional crush (is he still a hero if he doesn’t get the girl he should?) and then, in grade 9, at 13, I met Mr. Darcy. Sigh. He was probably my first grown up book crush. But then, how could you not fall in love with Me. Darcy?

    Reply
  53. Gilbert Blythe from Anne of Green Gables won my 10 year old heart. He was so persistent and faithful in light of Anne’s disinterest. I was so upset that Jo March inutile Women turned her nose up at Laurie, my second fictional crush (is he still a hero if he doesn’t get the girl he should?) and then, in grade 9, at 13, I met Mr. Darcy. Sigh. He was probably my first grown up book crush. But then, how could you not fall in love with Me. Darcy?

    Reply
  54. Gilbert Blythe from Anne of Green Gables won my 10 year old heart. He was so persistent and faithful in light of Anne’s disinterest. I was so upset that Jo March inutile Women turned her nose up at Laurie, my second fictional crush (is he still a hero if he doesn’t get the girl he should?) and then, in grade 9, at 13, I met Mr. Darcy. Sigh. He was probably my first grown up book crush. But then, how could you not fall in love with Me. Darcy?

    Reply
  55. Gilbert Blythe from Anne of Green Gables won my 10 year old heart. He was so persistent and faithful in light of Anne’s disinterest. I was so upset that Jo March inutile Women turned her nose up at Laurie, my second fictional crush (is he still a hero if he doesn’t get the girl he should?) and then, in grade 9, at 13, I met Mr. Darcy. Sigh. He was probably my first grown up book crush. But then, how could you not fall in love with Me. Darcy?

    Reply
  56. My very first crush was Sidney Carton in A Tale of Two Cities. I think I was about 10, and found his tragic self-sacrifice irresistible. As an adult I read A Far Better Rest by Susanne Alleyn, which is the story of Carton’s life between meeting the Manets and his destiny on the scaffold, and I fell in love all over again. The books about my other major teenage crush did not hold up well at all. I discovered Joffrey de Peyrac of the Angelique books by Sergeanne Golon, another tragic hero. I loved his intelligence, poetry, and mastery of his own life. But the books themselves, as I read them as an adult, read more like Angelique Does Versailles.

    Reply
  57. My very first crush was Sidney Carton in A Tale of Two Cities. I think I was about 10, and found his tragic self-sacrifice irresistible. As an adult I read A Far Better Rest by Susanne Alleyn, which is the story of Carton’s life between meeting the Manets and his destiny on the scaffold, and I fell in love all over again. The books about my other major teenage crush did not hold up well at all. I discovered Joffrey de Peyrac of the Angelique books by Sergeanne Golon, another tragic hero. I loved his intelligence, poetry, and mastery of his own life. But the books themselves, as I read them as an adult, read more like Angelique Does Versailles.

    Reply
  58. My very first crush was Sidney Carton in A Tale of Two Cities. I think I was about 10, and found his tragic self-sacrifice irresistible. As an adult I read A Far Better Rest by Susanne Alleyn, which is the story of Carton’s life between meeting the Manets and his destiny on the scaffold, and I fell in love all over again. The books about my other major teenage crush did not hold up well at all. I discovered Joffrey de Peyrac of the Angelique books by Sergeanne Golon, another tragic hero. I loved his intelligence, poetry, and mastery of his own life. But the books themselves, as I read them as an adult, read more like Angelique Does Versailles.

    Reply
  59. My very first crush was Sidney Carton in A Tale of Two Cities. I think I was about 10, and found his tragic self-sacrifice irresistible. As an adult I read A Far Better Rest by Susanne Alleyn, which is the story of Carton’s life between meeting the Manets and his destiny on the scaffold, and I fell in love all over again. The books about my other major teenage crush did not hold up well at all. I discovered Joffrey de Peyrac of the Angelique books by Sergeanne Golon, another tragic hero. I loved his intelligence, poetry, and mastery of his own life. But the books themselves, as I read them as an adult, read more like Angelique Does Versailles.

    Reply
  60. My very first crush was Sidney Carton in A Tale of Two Cities. I think I was about 10, and found his tragic self-sacrifice irresistible. As an adult I read A Far Better Rest by Susanne Alleyn, which is the story of Carton’s life between meeting the Manets and his destiny on the scaffold, and I fell in love all over again. The books about my other major teenage crush did not hold up well at all. I discovered Joffrey de Peyrac of the Angelique books by Sergeanne Golon, another tragic hero. I loved his intelligence, poetry, and mastery of his own life. But the books themselves, as I read them as an adult, read more like Angelique Does Versailles.

    Reply
  61. Justin and Vidal from Georgette are favourites of mine but Anne has already claimed them *sniff*. so who popped into my head next… Gideon from Amanda Quicks Ravished, a book I have reread so often it now has no front or back covers on it, shades of beauty and the beast I know, but I really loved him.

    Reply
  62. Justin and Vidal from Georgette are favourites of mine but Anne has already claimed them *sniff*. so who popped into my head next… Gideon from Amanda Quicks Ravished, a book I have reread so often it now has no front or back covers on it, shades of beauty and the beast I know, but I really loved him.

    Reply
  63. Justin and Vidal from Georgette are favourites of mine but Anne has already claimed them *sniff*. so who popped into my head next… Gideon from Amanda Quicks Ravished, a book I have reread so often it now has no front or back covers on it, shades of beauty and the beast I know, but I really loved him.

    Reply
  64. Justin and Vidal from Georgette are favourites of mine but Anne has already claimed them *sniff*. so who popped into my head next… Gideon from Amanda Quicks Ravished, a book I have reread so often it now has no front or back covers on it, shades of beauty and the beast I know, but I really loved him.

    Reply
  65. Justin and Vidal from Georgette are favourites of mine but Anne has already claimed them *sniff*. so who popped into my head next… Gideon from Amanda Quicks Ravished, a book I have reread so often it now has no front or back covers on it, shades of beauty and the beast I know, but I really loved him.

    Reply
  66. Ivanhoe was probably my first mega hero tho probably strongly influenced by a children’s film series about ‘the Black Knight’. Then came Sir Percy Blakeney and I think he still holds sway tho I loved most of Heyers heroes. I think my favorite heroes all have to have a sense of humour.Slim and elegant ,big and beefy they all need to have that light side and probably have to like animals as well !!

    Reply
  67. Ivanhoe was probably my first mega hero tho probably strongly influenced by a children’s film series about ‘the Black Knight’. Then came Sir Percy Blakeney and I think he still holds sway tho I loved most of Heyers heroes. I think my favorite heroes all have to have a sense of humour.Slim and elegant ,big and beefy they all need to have that light side and probably have to like animals as well !!

    Reply
  68. Ivanhoe was probably my first mega hero tho probably strongly influenced by a children’s film series about ‘the Black Knight’. Then came Sir Percy Blakeney and I think he still holds sway tho I loved most of Heyers heroes. I think my favorite heroes all have to have a sense of humour.Slim and elegant ,big and beefy they all need to have that light side and probably have to like animals as well !!

    Reply
  69. Ivanhoe was probably my first mega hero tho probably strongly influenced by a children’s film series about ‘the Black Knight’. Then came Sir Percy Blakeney and I think he still holds sway tho I loved most of Heyers heroes. I think my favorite heroes all have to have a sense of humour.Slim and elegant ,big and beefy they all need to have that light side and probably have to like animals as well !!

    Reply
  70. Ivanhoe was probably my first mega hero tho probably strongly influenced by a children’s film series about ‘the Black Knight’. Then came Sir Percy Blakeney and I think he still holds sway tho I loved most of Heyers heroes. I think my favorite heroes all have to have a sense of humour.Slim and elegant ,big and beefy they all need to have that light side and probably have to like animals as well !!

    Reply
  71. Peaceable Drummond in “The Sherwood Ring” during my teens, and then Francis Crawford when I was 21. Forty years later, it’s still Lymond, although if I had met Joanna Bourne’s Hawk, it would have been a very close race.

    Reply
  72. Peaceable Drummond in “The Sherwood Ring” during my teens, and then Francis Crawford when I was 21. Forty years later, it’s still Lymond, although if I had met Joanna Bourne’s Hawk, it would have been a very close race.

    Reply
  73. Peaceable Drummond in “The Sherwood Ring” during my teens, and then Francis Crawford when I was 21. Forty years later, it’s still Lymond, although if I had met Joanna Bourne’s Hawk, it would have been a very close race.

    Reply
  74. Peaceable Drummond in “The Sherwood Ring” during my teens, and then Francis Crawford when I was 21. Forty years later, it’s still Lymond, although if I had met Joanna Bourne’s Hawk, it would have been a very close race.

    Reply
  75. Peaceable Drummond in “The Sherwood Ring” during my teens, and then Francis Crawford when I was 21. Forty years later, it’s still Lymond, although if I had met Joanna Bourne’s Hawk, it would have been a very close race.

    Reply
  76. I also loved Alan Breck Stewart in Kidnapped when I first read it – he was strong, mysterious and good under it all, and I’ve sympathized with the Jacobites ever since.

    Reply
  77. I also loved Alan Breck Stewart in Kidnapped when I first read it – he was strong, mysterious and good under it all, and I’ve sympathized with the Jacobites ever since.

    Reply
  78. I also loved Alan Breck Stewart in Kidnapped when I first read it – he was strong, mysterious and good under it all, and I’ve sympathized with the Jacobites ever since.

    Reply
  79. I also loved Alan Breck Stewart in Kidnapped when I first read it – he was strong, mysterious and good under it all, and I’ve sympathized with the Jacobites ever since.

    Reply
  80. I also loved Alan Breck Stewart in Kidnapped when I first read it – he was strong, mysterious and good under it all, and I’ve sympathized with the Jacobites ever since.

    Reply
  81. I read all of Daphne De Maurier’s novels in high school, and I loved the heroes in Frenchman’s Creek, Jamaica Inn – and dear Max from Rebecca too. Very much so.

    Reply
  82. I read all of Daphne De Maurier’s novels in high school, and I loved the heroes in Frenchman’s Creek, Jamaica Inn – and dear Max from Rebecca too. Very much so.

    Reply
  83. I read all of Daphne De Maurier’s novels in high school, and I loved the heroes in Frenchman’s Creek, Jamaica Inn – and dear Max from Rebecca too. Very much so.

    Reply
  84. I read all of Daphne De Maurier’s novels in high school, and I loved the heroes in Frenchman’s Creek, Jamaica Inn – and dear Max from Rebecca too. Very much so.

    Reply
  85. I read all of Daphne De Maurier’s novels in high school, and I loved the heroes in Frenchman’s Creek, Jamaica Inn – and dear Max from Rebecca too. Very much so.

    Reply
  86. HJ, You’ve just named my two favorite mary Stewart heroes. I have a theory that any romance writer who writes a hero called Raoul, fell heavily for Raoul de Valmy in Nine Coaches Waiting. I have yet to write mine.

    Reply
  87. HJ, You’ve just named my two favorite mary Stewart heroes. I have a theory that any romance writer who writes a hero called Raoul, fell heavily for Raoul de Valmy in Nine Coaches Waiting. I have yet to write mine.

    Reply
  88. HJ, You’ve just named my two favorite mary Stewart heroes. I have a theory that any romance writer who writes a hero called Raoul, fell heavily for Raoul de Valmy in Nine Coaches Waiting. I have yet to write mine.

    Reply
  89. HJ, You’ve just named my two favorite mary Stewart heroes. I have a theory that any romance writer who writes a hero called Raoul, fell heavily for Raoul de Valmy in Nine Coaches Waiting. I have yet to write mine.

    Reply
  90. HJ, You’ve just named my two favorite mary Stewart heroes. I have a theory that any romance writer who writes a hero called Raoul, fell heavily for Raoul de Valmy in Nine Coaches Waiting. I have yet to write mine.

    Reply
  91. Richard or Dick in Violet Needham’s Stormy Petrel series. I spent days when reading these books trying to imagine living in this country. And Malcom Saville’s books. I read every one I could get my hands on when I was about 12 years old. I loved his heroes. The one that has stayed with me all my life is D’Artagnan. Every time I read The Three Musketeers I imagine living in that time. It is probably still my favourite.

    Reply
  92. Richard or Dick in Violet Needham’s Stormy Petrel series. I spent days when reading these books trying to imagine living in this country. And Malcom Saville’s books. I read every one I could get my hands on when I was about 12 years old. I loved his heroes. The one that has stayed with me all my life is D’Artagnan. Every time I read The Three Musketeers I imagine living in that time. It is probably still my favourite.

    Reply
  93. Richard or Dick in Violet Needham’s Stormy Petrel series. I spent days when reading these books trying to imagine living in this country. And Malcom Saville’s books. I read every one I could get my hands on when I was about 12 years old. I loved his heroes. The one that has stayed with me all my life is D’Artagnan. Every time I read The Three Musketeers I imagine living in that time. It is probably still my favourite.

    Reply
  94. Richard or Dick in Violet Needham’s Stormy Petrel series. I spent days when reading these books trying to imagine living in this country. And Malcom Saville’s books. I read every one I could get my hands on when I was about 12 years old. I loved his heroes. The one that has stayed with me all my life is D’Artagnan. Every time I read The Three Musketeers I imagine living in that time. It is probably still my favourite.

    Reply
  95. Richard or Dick in Violet Needham’s Stormy Petrel series. I spent days when reading these books trying to imagine living in this country. And Malcom Saville’s books. I read every one I could get my hands on when I was about 12 years old. I loved his heroes. The one that has stayed with me all my life is D’Artagnan. Every time I read The Three Musketeers I imagine living in that time. It is probably still my favourite.

    Reply
  96. My first book crush … Richard Byron from Madam Will You Talk, he had it all. Ex fighter pilot, handsome,intelligent,tortured past. AND he’s the only hero who could get away with calling his heroine a “beautiful bitch” without being clobbered with a Le Creuset,and still walk off into the sunset with his lady.35 years,and the crush is still in full force. Great writing never dies 🙂

    Reply
  97. My first book crush … Richard Byron from Madam Will You Talk, he had it all. Ex fighter pilot, handsome,intelligent,tortured past. AND he’s the only hero who could get away with calling his heroine a “beautiful bitch” without being clobbered with a Le Creuset,and still walk off into the sunset with his lady.35 years,and the crush is still in full force. Great writing never dies 🙂

    Reply
  98. My first book crush … Richard Byron from Madam Will You Talk, he had it all. Ex fighter pilot, handsome,intelligent,tortured past. AND he’s the only hero who could get away with calling his heroine a “beautiful bitch” without being clobbered with a Le Creuset,and still walk off into the sunset with his lady.35 years,and the crush is still in full force. Great writing never dies 🙂

    Reply
  99. My first book crush … Richard Byron from Madam Will You Talk, he had it all. Ex fighter pilot, handsome,intelligent,tortured past. AND he’s the only hero who could get away with calling his heroine a “beautiful bitch” without being clobbered with a Le Creuset,and still walk off into the sunset with his lady.35 years,and the crush is still in full force. Great writing never dies 🙂

    Reply
  100. My first book crush … Richard Byron from Madam Will You Talk, he had it all. Ex fighter pilot, handsome,intelligent,tortured past. AND he’s the only hero who could get away with calling his heroine a “beautiful bitch” without being clobbered with a Le Creuset,and still walk off into the sunset with his lady.35 years,and the crush is still in full force. Great writing never dies 🙂

    Reply
  101. The very first books was “The Countess de Monsoreau” and “The Count of Monte Cristo.” I cried when he was killed Bussy. I was outraged when Edmond Dantes was imprisoned and very moved in the final of book – the heart of the Avenger opened for love. But later I discovered the world of books Anne and Serge Golon “Angelica”. De Peyrac – what a man! Although it is now the heart flutters, it is worth to take one)

    Reply
  102. The very first books was “The Countess de Monsoreau” and “The Count of Monte Cristo.” I cried when he was killed Bussy. I was outraged when Edmond Dantes was imprisoned and very moved in the final of book – the heart of the Avenger opened for love. But later I discovered the world of books Anne and Serge Golon “Angelica”. De Peyrac – what a man! Although it is now the heart flutters, it is worth to take one)

    Reply
  103. The very first books was “The Countess de Monsoreau” and “The Count of Monte Cristo.” I cried when he was killed Bussy. I was outraged when Edmond Dantes was imprisoned and very moved in the final of book – the heart of the Avenger opened for love. But later I discovered the world of books Anne and Serge Golon “Angelica”. De Peyrac – what a man! Although it is now the heart flutters, it is worth to take one)

    Reply
  104. The very first books was “The Countess de Monsoreau” and “The Count of Monte Cristo.” I cried when he was killed Bussy. I was outraged when Edmond Dantes was imprisoned and very moved in the final of book – the heart of the Avenger opened for love. But later I discovered the world of books Anne and Serge Golon “Angelica”. De Peyrac – what a man! Although it is now the heart flutters, it is worth to take one)

    Reply
  105. The very first books was “The Countess de Monsoreau” and “The Count of Monte Cristo.” I cried when he was killed Bussy. I was outraged when Edmond Dantes was imprisoned and very moved in the final of book – the heart of the Avenger opened for love. But later I discovered the world of books Anne and Serge Golon “Angelica”. De Peyrac – what a man! Although it is now the heart flutters, it is worth to take one)

    Reply
  106. I think my very first crush was Lord Sheftu in Mara Daughter of the Nile. I think I fell in love with the entire book 🙂 After that, probably Lord Peter Wimsey, whom I still like even though he makes me wince once in a while; I have to reread or relisten to Murder Must Advertise at least once a year. The first crush from a genre romance was probably the Duke of Avon, whom I still adore without reservation 🙂

    Reply
  107. I think my very first crush was Lord Sheftu in Mara Daughter of the Nile. I think I fell in love with the entire book 🙂 After that, probably Lord Peter Wimsey, whom I still like even though he makes me wince once in a while; I have to reread or relisten to Murder Must Advertise at least once a year. The first crush from a genre romance was probably the Duke of Avon, whom I still adore without reservation 🙂

    Reply
  108. I think my very first crush was Lord Sheftu in Mara Daughter of the Nile. I think I fell in love with the entire book 🙂 After that, probably Lord Peter Wimsey, whom I still like even though he makes me wince once in a while; I have to reread or relisten to Murder Must Advertise at least once a year. The first crush from a genre romance was probably the Duke of Avon, whom I still adore without reservation 🙂

    Reply
  109. I think my very first crush was Lord Sheftu in Mara Daughter of the Nile. I think I fell in love with the entire book 🙂 After that, probably Lord Peter Wimsey, whom I still like even though he makes me wince once in a while; I have to reread or relisten to Murder Must Advertise at least once a year. The first crush from a genre romance was probably the Duke of Avon, whom I still adore without reservation 🙂

    Reply
  110. I think my very first crush was Lord Sheftu in Mara Daughter of the Nile. I think I fell in love with the entire book 🙂 After that, probably Lord Peter Wimsey, whom I still like even though he makes me wince once in a while; I have to reread or relisten to Murder Must Advertise at least once a year. The first crush from a genre romance was probably the Duke of Avon, whom I still adore without reservation 🙂

    Reply
  111. Caramouche by Sabatini Birn with a Gift of laughter and the sense that the world was mad.
    hough I really didn’t get swoony over men in print except Richard Haliburton who wrote the Royal Road to Romance. the first fictional characters I ever envied were the Bobbsey twins– I wanted to be one or to have three sets of twins ( God was kind and gave me 3 single births.) I probably wanted to be Nancy Drew and admired Perry Mason and Ellery Queen. I never wanted any of the men as a husband or lover nor sighed with envy about any of them. I did like the stories they were in.
    The Scarlet Pimpernel and Lord Peter were later acquaintances. I like Capt. Wentworth better than Darcy ,

    Reply
  112. Caramouche by Sabatini Birn with a Gift of laughter and the sense that the world was mad.
    hough I really didn’t get swoony over men in print except Richard Haliburton who wrote the Royal Road to Romance. the first fictional characters I ever envied were the Bobbsey twins– I wanted to be one or to have three sets of twins ( God was kind and gave me 3 single births.) I probably wanted to be Nancy Drew and admired Perry Mason and Ellery Queen. I never wanted any of the men as a husband or lover nor sighed with envy about any of them. I did like the stories they were in.
    The Scarlet Pimpernel and Lord Peter were later acquaintances. I like Capt. Wentworth better than Darcy ,

    Reply
  113. Caramouche by Sabatini Birn with a Gift of laughter and the sense that the world was mad.
    hough I really didn’t get swoony over men in print except Richard Haliburton who wrote the Royal Road to Romance. the first fictional characters I ever envied were the Bobbsey twins– I wanted to be one or to have three sets of twins ( God was kind and gave me 3 single births.) I probably wanted to be Nancy Drew and admired Perry Mason and Ellery Queen. I never wanted any of the men as a husband or lover nor sighed with envy about any of them. I did like the stories they were in.
    The Scarlet Pimpernel and Lord Peter were later acquaintances. I like Capt. Wentworth better than Darcy ,

    Reply
  114. Caramouche by Sabatini Birn with a Gift of laughter and the sense that the world was mad.
    hough I really didn’t get swoony over men in print except Richard Haliburton who wrote the Royal Road to Romance. the first fictional characters I ever envied were the Bobbsey twins– I wanted to be one or to have three sets of twins ( God was kind and gave me 3 single births.) I probably wanted to be Nancy Drew and admired Perry Mason and Ellery Queen. I never wanted any of the men as a husband or lover nor sighed with envy about any of them. I did like the stories they were in.
    The Scarlet Pimpernel and Lord Peter were later acquaintances. I like Capt. Wentworth better than Darcy ,

    Reply
  115. Caramouche by Sabatini Birn with a Gift of laughter and the sense that the world was mad.
    hough I really didn’t get swoony over men in print except Richard Haliburton who wrote the Royal Road to Romance. the first fictional characters I ever envied were the Bobbsey twins– I wanted to be one or to have three sets of twins ( God was kind and gave me 3 single births.) I probably wanted to be Nancy Drew and admired Perry Mason and Ellery Queen. I never wanted any of the men as a husband or lover nor sighed with envy about any of them. I did like the stories they were in.
    The Scarlet Pimpernel and Lord Peter were later acquaintances. I like Capt. Wentworth better than Darcy ,

    Reply
  116. What a great hero! I love all of Stewart’s heroes, and other favorites are Nicholas in Wildfire at Midnight and the mysterious Lewis in Airs Above the Ground. I particularly love their understated assurance and quiet sexiness. Reading her novels in high school and college not only helped me to form my ideal fictional hero, but also clarified the sort of guy I was attracted to in real life. 😉

    Reply
  117. What a great hero! I love all of Stewart’s heroes, and other favorites are Nicholas in Wildfire at Midnight and the mysterious Lewis in Airs Above the Ground. I particularly love their understated assurance and quiet sexiness. Reading her novels in high school and college not only helped me to form my ideal fictional hero, but also clarified the sort of guy I was attracted to in real life. 😉

    Reply
  118. What a great hero! I love all of Stewart’s heroes, and other favorites are Nicholas in Wildfire at Midnight and the mysterious Lewis in Airs Above the Ground. I particularly love their understated assurance and quiet sexiness. Reading her novels in high school and college not only helped me to form my ideal fictional hero, but also clarified the sort of guy I was attracted to in real life. 😉

    Reply
  119. What a great hero! I love all of Stewart’s heroes, and other favorites are Nicholas in Wildfire at Midnight and the mysterious Lewis in Airs Above the Ground. I particularly love their understated assurance and quiet sexiness. Reading her novels in high school and college not only helped me to form my ideal fictional hero, but also clarified the sort of guy I was attracted to in real life. 😉

    Reply
  120. What a great hero! I love all of Stewart’s heroes, and other favorites are Nicholas in Wildfire at Midnight and the mysterious Lewis in Airs Above the Ground. I particularly love their understated assurance and quiet sexiness. Reading her novels in high school and college not only helped me to form my ideal fictional hero, but also clarified the sort of guy I was attracted to in real life. 😉

    Reply
  121. I was delighted to see Hugo from Heyer’s Unknown Ajax on the list, and Dunnett’s Francis Crawford of Lymond – oh, all of them, really. But the *most* fun for me was to read the Wench favorites and smile over how they’ve appeared in various guises in your books. Started my day off right!

    Reply
  122. I was delighted to see Hugo from Heyer’s Unknown Ajax on the list, and Dunnett’s Francis Crawford of Lymond – oh, all of them, really. But the *most* fun for me was to read the Wench favorites and smile over how they’ve appeared in various guises in your books. Started my day off right!

    Reply
  123. I was delighted to see Hugo from Heyer’s Unknown Ajax on the list, and Dunnett’s Francis Crawford of Lymond – oh, all of them, really. But the *most* fun for me was to read the Wench favorites and smile over how they’ve appeared in various guises in your books. Started my day off right!

    Reply
  124. I was delighted to see Hugo from Heyer’s Unknown Ajax on the list, and Dunnett’s Francis Crawford of Lymond – oh, all of them, really. But the *most* fun for me was to read the Wench favorites and smile over how they’ve appeared in various guises in your books. Started my day off right!

    Reply
  125. I was delighted to see Hugo from Heyer’s Unknown Ajax on the list, and Dunnett’s Francis Crawford of Lymond – oh, all of them, really. But the *most* fun for me was to read the Wench favorites and smile over how they’ve appeared in various guises in your books. Started my day off right!

    Reply
  126. Sigh, how lovely to remember all my early crushes. My mother had Mary Stewart novels, so they were some of my early favorites. But I don’t remember the heroes much… just the heroines and the settings. I DO remember the Heyer novels. Vidal — the ultimate bad boy with a good heart. He still makes my pulse flutter, although I’d run a mile if I met him in real life. Mr. Beaumaris from Arabella is more my style. The Duke of Lancaster in Katherine, by Anya Seton took my fancy. Crawford of Lymond is the template against whom I measure my heroes: incredibly talented in music, sports, literature, hilarious sense of humor, and a rock-solid sense of honor.

    Reply
  127. Sigh, how lovely to remember all my early crushes. My mother had Mary Stewart novels, so they were some of my early favorites. But I don’t remember the heroes much… just the heroines and the settings. I DO remember the Heyer novels. Vidal — the ultimate bad boy with a good heart. He still makes my pulse flutter, although I’d run a mile if I met him in real life. Mr. Beaumaris from Arabella is more my style. The Duke of Lancaster in Katherine, by Anya Seton took my fancy. Crawford of Lymond is the template against whom I measure my heroes: incredibly talented in music, sports, literature, hilarious sense of humor, and a rock-solid sense of honor.

    Reply
  128. Sigh, how lovely to remember all my early crushes. My mother had Mary Stewart novels, so they were some of my early favorites. But I don’t remember the heroes much… just the heroines and the settings. I DO remember the Heyer novels. Vidal — the ultimate bad boy with a good heart. He still makes my pulse flutter, although I’d run a mile if I met him in real life. Mr. Beaumaris from Arabella is more my style. The Duke of Lancaster in Katherine, by Anya Seton took my fancy. Crawford of Lymond is the template against whom I measure my heroes: incredibly talented in music, sports, literature, hilarious sense of humor, and a rock-solid sense of honor.

    Reply
  129. Sigh, how lovely to remember all my early crushes. My mother had Mary Stewart novels, so they were some of my early favorites. But I don’t remember the heroes much… just the heroines and the settings. I DO remember the Heyer novels. Vidal — the ultimate bad boy with a good heart. He still makes my pulse flutter, although I’d run a mile if I met him in real life. Mr. Beaumaris from Arabella is more my style. The Duke of Lancaster in Katherine, by Anya Seton took my fancy. Crawford of Lymond is the template against whom I measure my heroes: incredibly talented in music, sports, literature, hilarious sense of humor, and a rock-solid sense of honor.

    Reply
  130. Sigh, how lovely to remember all my early crushes. My mother had Mary Stewart novels, so they were some of my early favorites. But I don’t remember the heroes much… just the heroines and the settings. I DO remember the Heyer novels. Vidal — the ultimate bad boy with a good heart. He still makes my pulse flutter, although I’d run a mile if I met him in real life. Mr. Beaumaris from Arabella is more my style. The Duke of Lancaster in Katherine, by Anya Seton took my fancy. Crawford of Lymond is the template against whom I measure my heroes: incredibly talented in music, sports, literature, hilarious sense of humor, and a rock-solid sense of honor.

    Reply
  131. Haha! Yes, Humphrey was one of those resourceful heroes who would be great to have around when the cavaliers had flounced off to keep their lace clean! I loved Children of the New Forest. I read it again recently and was still enchanted by it.

    Reply
  132. Haha! Yes, Humphrey was one of those resourceful heroes who would be great to have around when the cavaliers had flounced off to keep their lace clean! I loved Children of the New Forest. I read it again recently and was still enchanted by it.

    Reply
  133. Haha! Yes, Humphrey was one of those resourceful heroes who would be great to have around when the cavaliers had flounced off to keep their lace clean! I loved Children of the New Forest. I read it again recently and was still enchanted by it.

    Reply
  134. Haha! Yes, Humphrey was one of those resourceful heroes who would be great to have around when the cavaliers had flounced off to keep their lace clean! I loved Children of the New Forest. I read it again recently and was still enchanted by it.

    Reply
  135. Haha! Yes, Humphrey was one of those resourceful heroes who would be great to have around when the cavaliers had flounced off to keep their lace clean! I loved Children of the New Forest. I read it again recently and was still enchanted by it.

    Reply
  136. My very first hero was Sydney Carton from A Tale of Two Cities, his self sacrificing love for Lucy Manet, heartand “It’s a far, far better thing I do, than I have ever done before” just blew me away. I was in my teens, but I’m a late bloomer. I did not meet his equal until Lord Michael Kenyon in “Shattered Rainbows”. He holds the crown in this old (85) lady’s heart

    Reply
  137. My very first hero was Sydney Carton from A Tale of Two Cities, his self sacrificing love for Lucy Manet, heartand “It’s a far, far better thing I do, than I have ever done before” just blew me away. I was in my teens, but I’m a late bloomer. I did not meet his equal until Lord Michael Kenyon in “Shattered Rainbows”. He holds the crown in this old (85) lady’s heart

    Reply
  138. My very first hero was Sydney Carton from A Tale of Two Cities, his self sacrificing love for Lucy Manet, heartand “It’s a far, far better thing I do, than I have ever done before” just blew me away. I was in my teens, but I’m a late bloomer. I did not meet his equal until Lord Michael Kenyon in “Shattered Rainbows”. He holds the crown in this old (85) lady’s heart

    Reply
  139. My very first hero was Sydney Carton from A Tale of Two Cities, his self sacrificing love for Lucy Manet, heartand “It’s a far, far better thing I do, than I have ever done before” just blew me away. I was in my teens, but I’m a late bloomer. I did not meet his equal until Lord Michael Kenyon in “Shattered Rainbows”. He holds the crown in this old (85) lady’s heart

    Reply
  140. My very first hero was Sydney Carton from A Tale of Two Cities, his self sacrificing love for Lucy Manet, heartand “It’s a far, far better thing I do, than I have ever done before” just blew me away. I was in my teens, but I’m a late bloomer. I did not meet his equal until Lord Michael Kenyon in “Shattered Rainbows”. He holds the crown in this old (85) lady’s heart

    Reply
  141. Interesting how many of us liked Sydney Carton – it’s been quite a while, but I remember how much I liked and respected his character. Time to pull out TOFTC and check it out again. And what a great compliment for Mary Jo’s Michael Kenyon. 🙂

    Reply
  142. Interesting how many of us liked Sydney Carton – it’s been quite a while, but I remember how much I liked and respected his character. Time to pull out TOFTC and check it out again. And what a great compliment for Mary Jo’s Michael Kenyon. 🙂

    Reply
  143. Interesting how many of us liked Sydney Carton – it’s been quite a while, but I remember how much I liked and respected his character. Time to pull out TOFTC and check it out again. And what a great compliment for Mary Jo’s Michael Kenyon. 🙂

    Reply
  144. Interesting how many of us liked Sydney Carton – it’s been quite a while, but I remember how much I liked and respected his character. Time to pull out TOFTC and check it out again. And what a great compliment for Mary Jo’s Michael Kenyon. 🙂

    Reply
  145. Interesting how many of us liked Sydney Carton – it’s been quite a while, but I remember how much I liked and respected his character. Time to pull out TOFTC and check it out again. And what a great compliment for Mary Jo’s Michael Kenyon. 🙂

    Reply
  146. I’m a bit of a contrarian on under-dogs. They get such a good deal in fiction, movies etc that I tend to side with the beleaguered establishment figure who’s trying to keep things on an even keel. Because in turmoil, a lot of innocent people get hurt.

    Reply
  147. I’m a bit of a contrarian on under-dogs. They get such a good deal in fiction, movies etc that I tend to side with the beleaguered establishment figure who’s trying to keep things on an even keel. Because in turmoil, a lot of innocent people get hurt.

    Reply
  148. I’m a bit of a contrarian on under-dogs. They get such a good deal in fiction, movies etc that I tend to side with the beleaguered establishment figure who’s trying to keep things on an even keel. Because in turmoil, a lot of innocent people get hurt.

    Reply
  149. I’m a bit of a contrarian on under-dogs. They get such a good deal in fiction, movies etc that I tend to side with the beleaguered establishment figure who’s trying to keep things on an even keel. Because in turmoil, a lot of innocent people get hurt.

    Reply
  150. I’m a bit of a contrarian on under-dogs. They get such a good deal in fiction, movies etc that I tend to side with the beleaguered establishment figure who’s trying to keep things on an even keel. Because in turmoil, a lot of innocent people get hurt.

    Reply
  151. Part of his power to attract is that he makes mistakes — sometimes on a massive scale, but as he says somewhere, he takes responsibility for them and does his best to fix the damage.

    Reply
  152. Part of his power to attract is that he makes mistakes — sometimes on a massive scale, but as he says somewhere, he takes responsibility for them and does his best to fix the damage.

    Reply
  153. Part of his power to attract is that he makes mistakes — sometimes on a massive scale, but as he says somewhere, he takes responsibility for them and does his best to fix the damage.

    Reply
  154. Part of his power to attract is that he makes mistakes — sometimes on a massive scale, but as he says somewhere, he takes responsibility for them and does his best to fix the damage.

    Reply
  155. Part of his power to attract is that he makes mistakes — sometimes on a massive scale, but as he says somewhere, he takes responsibility for them and does his best to fix the damage.

    Reply
  156. Francis Crawford of Lymond So complete I didn’t realize it (what is it that baby ducklings do?) until recently though I of course knew I read and reread the books from the age of eleven. So now and forever.

    Reply
  157. Francis Crawford of Lymond So complete I didn’t realize it (what is it that baby ducklings do?) until recently though I of course knew I read and reread the books from the age of eleven. So now and forever.

    Reply
  158. Francis Crawford of Lymond So complete I didn’t realize it (what is it that baby ducklings do?) until recently though I of course knew I read and reread the books from the age of eleven. So now and forever.

    Reply
  159. Francis Crawford of Lymond So complete I didn’t realize it (what is it that baby ducklings do?) until recently though I of course knew I read and reread the books from the age of eleven. So now and forever.

    Reply
  160. Francis Crawford of Lymond So complete I didn’t realize it (what is it that baby ducklings do?) until recently though I of course knew I read and reread the books from the age of eleven. So now and forever.

    Reply
  161. For me it is Crawford of Lymond hands down. I read The Game of Kings at 16 and I’ve been a sucker for the tortured hero ever since. Second place would be tough, but The Scarlet Pimpernel would be in the running.

    Reply
  162. For me it is Crawford of Lymond hands down. I read The Game of Kings at 16 and I’ve been a sucker for the tortured hero ever since. Second place would be tough, but The Scarlet Pimpernel would be in the running.

    Reply
  163. For me it is Crawford of Lymond hands down. I read The Game of Kings at 16 and I’ve been a sucker for the tortured hero ever since. Second place would be tough, but The Scarlet Pimpernel would be in the running.

    Reply
  164. For me it is Crawford of Lymond hands down. I read The Game of Kings at 16 and I’ve been a sucker for the tortured hero ever since. Second place would be tough, but The Scarlet Pimpernel would be in the running.

    Reply
  165. For me it is Crawford of Lymond hands down. I read The Game of Kings at 16 and I’ve been a sucker for the tortured hero ever since. Second place would be tough, but The Scarlet Pimpernel would be in the running.

    Reply
  166. We adopted her from China, so she has dark brown eyes. I always loved the name, and fortunately my husband did also. So, 30 years after I read the book, I got my Mara.

    Reply
  167. We adopted her from China, so she has dark brown eyes. I always loved the name, and fortunately my husband did also. So, 30 years after I read the book, I got my Mara.

    Reply
  168. We adopted her from China, so she has dark brown eyes. I always loved the name, and fortunately my husband did also. So, 30 years after I read the book, I got my Mara.

    Reply
  169. We adopted her from China, so she has dark brown eyes. I always loved the name, and fortunately my husband did also. So, 30 years after I read the book, I got my Mara.

    Reply
  170. We adopted her from China, so she has dark brown eyes. I always loved the name, and fortunately my husband did also. So, 30 years after I read the book, I got my Mara.

    Reply
  171. I know this is off subject, but I waited until everyone else had posted and a weekend has passed.
    What has happened to Sherrie and what is happening with her cat? Nothing has been posted for almost a month. Could someone let us know? Thanks.

    Reply
  172. I know this is off subject, but I waited until everyone else had posted and a weekend has passed.
    What has happened to Sherrie and what is happening with her cat? Nothing has been posted for almost a month. Could someone let us know? Thanks.

    Reply
  173. I know this is off subject, but I waited until everyone else had posted and a weekend has passed.
    What has happened to Sherrie and what is happening with her cat? Nothing has been posted for almost a month. Could someone let us know? Thanks.

    Reply
  174. I know this is off subject, but I waited until everyone else had posted and a weekend has passed.
    What has happened to Sherrie and what is happening with her cat? Nothing has been posted for almost a month. Could someone let us know? Thanks.

    Reply
  175. I know this is off subject, but I waited until everyone else had posted and a weekend has passed.
    What has happened to Sherrie and what is happening with her cat? Nothing has been posted for almost a month. Could someone let us know? Thanks.

    Reply
  176. Sherrie’s had some intermittent computer challenges lately, Diane – she and Sparky are both doing fine, and Sparky is up to her usual shenanigans. Meanwhile, we’ve resumed Word Wench news postings on Sundays. Thanks for asking!

    Reply
  177. Sherrie’s had some intermittent computer challenges lately, Diane – she and Sparky are both doing fine, and Sparky is up to her usual shenanigans. Meanwhile, we’ve resumed Word Wench news postings on Sundays. Thanks for asking!

    Reply
  178. Sherrie’s had some intermittent computer challenges lately, Diane – she and Sparky are both doing fine, and Sparky is up to her usual shenanigans. Meanwhile, we’ve resumed Word Wench news postings on Sundays. Thanks for asking!

    Reply
  179. Sherrie’s had some intermittent computer challenges lately, Diane – she and Sparky are both doing fine, and Sparky is up to her usual shenanigans. Meanwhile, we’ve resumed Word Wench news postings on Sundays. Thanks for asking!

    Reply
  180. Sherrie’s had some intermittent computer challenges lately, Diane – she and Sparky are both doing fine, and Sparky is up to her usual shenanigans. Meanwhile, we’ve resumed Word Wench news postings on Sundays. Thanks for asking!

    Reply

Leave a Comment