Princess Caraboo

JobigblueHi, here's Jo with one of those stories that proves the saying that truth is stranger than fiction. If any of us wrote this as a novel, we'd be ridiculed.

In 1817 a quick-witted, penniless young woman persuaded local worthies and then some of thCare great that she was a lost princess from a foreign land. I decided to blog about this now not only because it's an engaging story, but because there's an enjoyable movie about it that might be a good choice for the lingering days of the summer holidays.

There's a complete account of the adventure available on googlebooks here and I'll start by quoting the opening.

"On Thursday evening the 3rd of April 1817, the
Overseer of the Poor of the parish of Almondsbury, in the county of
Gloucester, called at Knole Park, the residence of Samuel Worrall, Esq.
to inform that Gentleman and his Lady, that a young Female had entered a
cottage in the village, and had made signs, that it was her wish to
sleep under its roof; but not speaking a language, which its inhabitants
or the Overseer understood, the officer thought it right to refer to
Mr. Worrall, a Magistrate for the county, for his advice; knowing also,
that there was a man servant residing in Mr. Worrall's family, who was
conversant with several foreign languages, and who could probably
comprehend that in which the stranger spoke."

A little later we get a clear exposition of the situation of a vagrant in Regency England. "Upon Mrs. W.'s return from church, she summoned
the young woman before her; and fearful of imposition, she attempted to
interest the stranger by addressing her in the following soothing and
compassionate language; "My good young woman, I very much fear that you
are imposing upon me, and that you understand and can answer me in my
own language; if so, and distress has driven you to this expedient, make
a friend of me; I am a female as yourself, and can feel for you, and
will give you money and clothes, and will put you on your journey,
without disclosing your conduct to any one; but it must be on condition
that you speak the truth. If you deceive me, I think it right to inform
you, that Mr. W. is a Magistrate, and has the power of sending you to prison, committing you to hard labour, and passing you as a vagrant to your own parish."

The lost princess was in fact Mary Baker, and as best anyone can tell, she'd decided that foreigners had a better chance of being treated gently than English people, and then responded with quick wits to what happened. When shown scenes from foreign countries, she showed interest in Oriental ones, especially those from China.

She was obviously good at what she did, for she gained support from various people with knowledge of the East. Then she got really lucky with a Portuguese man who was clearly the sort to latch onto anything exciting public interest.

Carab"At last a foreigner of the
name of Manuel Eynesso, a
Portuguese from the Malay country, who happened to be in Bristol, was
introduced to her, and he declared that he could undertake to interpret
her language. The tale, this impostor pretended to extract from her,
was, briefly, that she was a person of consequence in her own country,
had been decoyed from an island in the East Indies, and brought to
England against her consent, and deserted. That the language she spoke
was not a pure dialect, bi>t a mixture of languages used on the coast
of Sumatra, and other islands in the East. This Manuel Eynesso in short
invented a story so plausible, and one so well suited to the imposition
the girl had determined to practice, that Mrs. W. was induced a second
time to take her to Knole, intending to communicate the particulars of
her history, as far as she could collect them, to some respectable
individual at the East India House, and extend her protection to her
till the truth of her story could be developed.
"

However, Mrs. Worrall intended to take the princess to London to be questioned by the East India Company, so Mary decided it was time to disappear. She'd previously intended to take ship to America and booked passage, but didn't have the money. That was why she'd gone wandering, hoping to find the means. Now that she had possessions of some value she took off for Bristol, but the ship had sailed.

Later, reason unclear, she ran away to Bath. Whether she intended it or not, she became a sensation with the great. When Mrs. Worrall tracked her down, she found this.

"The drawing room was crowded with fashionable visitants, all eager to be introduced to the interesting Princess. There
was one fair female kneeling before her, another taking her by the
hand, another begging a kiss !—The girl afterwards declared, that this
was the most trying scene she ever encountered, and that on this
occasion she had more difficulty to refrain from laughing, and escape
detection, than in all the singular occurrences of her life.
"

Mrs. Worrall took her back to Knole, for which the princess expressed gratitude, but the true story was beginning to emerge. It's all laid out in the book, but is too complicated to attempt here. Basically Mary was a clever girl who from a young age refused to settle to any position thought suitable for her, and who was both a survivor and a natural confidence trickster.

Probably keen to see the end of her, Mrs. Worrall bought her passage to America, where I'd have thought Mary would do well, but it seems her Princess Caraboo act didn't go so well there. She should have been capable of some other ruse, but perhaps she'd become addicted to life at the top. She returned to England and lived out her life in a humdrum way. The film gives her a happier ending.

As the author, of the book, John Mathew Gutch wraps up:   "That
an illiterate girl, unaided by education, in her usual manners and
common appearance by no means elegant or striking, and with no apparent
object, but an ambition to excel in deceit, should have so conducted
herself both in the language she made use of, and in her general
demeanour, as to have induced hundreds to believe, that she was no less a
personage than an unfortunate, unprotected, and wandering Princess from
a distant Eastern Island, cast upon the shores of Britain by cruel and
relentless Pirates;—that she should have sustained this character, with a
countenance never changed by the most abject flattery, or the most
abusive invective, constantly surrounded by persons of superior talent
and education, as well as by those in her own rank of life, who were
always on the watch to mark any inconsistency, or to catch at any
occurrence that could lead to detection ;—and that on no occasion was
she found to lose sight of the part she was acting, or once to betray
herself;—is an instance of consummate art and duplicity
exceeding any occurrence in the annals of modern imposture."

That's true, especially as it's claimed in the book that she was skilled with a bow and arrow and a sword!

The fun aspect of such period narratives is the sidelights to the time. What to make of this, included in the true story of Mary Baker?

"Being at this time very fond of finery, she applied the wages which she
received in the purchase of clothes, and then returned to her father's.
On her return he was much hurt to see her in white, and her mother
insisted on her taking it off, which she would not do. She staid there
only six days, during which time she saw her friend, and her old master
and mistress; but being dressed in white, they said, that she had
dishonestly procured it."

As I've always assumed with reason that shifts etc were white, I can only assume this means a white gown. Would a white muslin gown be so much more expensive, or was it the impractibility of it that ruled it out? Any idea?

Does any of this surprise you? In truth, people still get away with stunts like this if they have panache. We seem willing to believe the bold, and especially eager to believe extraordinary stories, especially about people from distant lands.

And yet, as I said, less forgiving in fiction. If this were written as a Regency Romance, how would you regard it?

Have you read any romances with equally implausible plots, and how did that work for you?

Cheers,

Jo

25 thoughts on “Princess Caraboo”

  1. From what I’ve seen in period records, white fabrics weren’t more expensive than other fabrics, but white gowns were considered highly impractical due to the work required to keep them white (and they wouldn’t have stayed white long if you were cooking, cleaning, tending to your chickens, etc.). I also get the general impression from period sources that it was sort of considered uppity to wear a white gown if you weren’t a lady of leisure (know your place and all that). I always think of the bit in Mansfield Park where two housemaids are turned away for wearing white gowns.

    Reply
  2. From what I’ve seen in period records, white fabrics weren’t more expensive than other fabrics, but white gowns were considered highly impractical due to the work required to keep them white (and they wouldn’t have stayed white long if you were cooking, cleaning, tending to your chickens, etc.). I also get the general impression from period sources that it was sort of considered uppity to wear a white gown if you weren’t a lady of leisure (know your place and all that). I always think of the bit in Mansfield Park where two housemaids are turned away for wearing white gowns.

    Reply
  3. From what I’ve seen in period records, white fabrics weren’t more expensive than other fabrics, but white gowns were considered highly impractical due to the work required to keep them white (and they wouldn’t have stayed white long if you were cooking, cleaning, tending to your chickens, etc.). I also get the general impression from period sources that it was sort of considered uppity to wear a white gown if you weren’t a lady of leisure (know your place and all that). I always think of the bit in Mansfield Park where two housemaids are turned away for wearing white gowns.

    Reply
  4. From what I’ve seen in period records, white fabrics weren’t more expensive than other fabrics, but white gowns were considered highly impractical due to the work required to keep them white (and they wouldn’t have stayed white long if you were cooking, cleaning, tending to your chickens, etc.). I also get the general impression from period sources that it was sort of considered uppity to wear a white gown if you weren’t a lady of leisure (know your place and all that). I always think of the bit in Mansfield Park where two housemaids are turned away for wearing white gowns.

    Reply
  5. From what I’ve seen in period records, white fabrics weren’t more expensive than other fabrics, but white gowns were considered highly impractical due to the work required to keep them white (and they wouldn’t have stayed white long if you were cooking, cleaning, tending to your chickens, etc.). I also get the general impression from period sources that it was sort of considered uppity to wear a white gown if you weren’t a lady of leisure (know your place and all that). I always think of the bit in Mansfield Park where two housemaids are turned away for wearing white gowns.

    Reply
  6. This story reminded me of the movie Catch Me If You Can, also a true story, and stranger than fiction! I could possibly see this as a Regency romance, but only if the confidence trickster wasn’t the heroine, but the baddie that the H or h uncover.
    Can’t think of any implausible plots – probably because the minute a plot becomes too implausible, I stop reading!

    Reply
  7. This story reminded me of the movie Catch Me If You Can, also a true story, and stranger than fiction! I could possibly see this as a Regency romance, but only if the confidence trickster wasn’t the heroine, but the baddie that the H or h uncover.
    Can’t think of any implausible plots – probably because the minute a plot becomes too implausible, I stop reading!

    Reply
  8. This story reminded me of the movie Catch Me If You Can, also a true story, and stranger than fiction! I could possibly see this as a Regency romance, but only if the confidence trickster wasn’t the heroine, but the baddie that the H or h uncover.
    Can’t think of any implausible plots – probably because the minute a plot becomes too implausible, I stop reading!

    Reply
  9. This story reminded me of the movie Catch Me If You Can, also a true story, and stranger than fiction! I could possibly see this as a Regency romance, but only if the confidence trickster wasn’t the heroine, but the baddie that the H or h uncover.
    Can’t think of any implausible plots – probably because the minute a plot becomes too implausible, I stop reading!

    Reply
  10. This story reminded me of the movie Catch Me If You Can, also a true story, and stranger than fiction! I could possibly see this as a Regency romance, but only if the confidence trickster wasn’t the heroine, but the baddie that the H or h uncover.
    Can’t think of any implausible plots – probably because the minute a plot becomes too implausible, I stop reading!

    Reply
  11. Jo–
    I first found the story of Princess Caraboo as a sidebar in a book about odd British bits of history. I was entranced, and got a kick out of the movie when it was made somewhat later. I even wrote a very fluffy novella called The Devil’s Spawn that was inspired by Princess Caraboo, only the mysterious Polynesia savage who turned up was the hero, who was desperate to get close to the only woman he’d ever loved, ten years after her father broke up the relationship. Fun. *G*
    Interesting about the white dresses! I didn’t remember the bit from Mansfield Park, but it does suggest the idea that for a working girl to wear white was quite uppity. Which certainly described Mary Baker!

    Reply
  12. Jo–
    I first found the story of Princess Caraboo as a sidebar in a book about odd British bits of history. I was entranced, and got a kick out of the movie when it was made somewhat later. I even wrote a very fluffy novella called The Devil’s Spawn that was inspired by Princess Caraboo, only the mysterious Polynesia savage who turned up was the hero, who was desperate to get close to the only woman he’d ever loved, ten years after her father broke up the relationship. Fun. *G*
    Interesting about the white dresses! I didn’t remember the bit from Mansfield Park, but it does suggest the idea that for a working girl to wear white was quite uppity. Which certainly described Mary Baker!

    Reply
  13. Jo–
    I first found the story of Princess Caraboo as a sidebar in a book about odd British bits of history. I was entranced, and got a kick out of the movie when it was made somewhat later. I even wrote a very fluffy novella called The Devil’s Spawn that was inspired by Princess Caraboo, only the mysterious Polynesia savage who turned up was the hero, who was desperate to get close to the only woman he’d ever loved, ten years after her father broke up the relationship. Fun. *G*
    Interesting about the white dresses! I didn’t remember the bit from Mansfield Park, but it does suggest the idea that for a working girl to wear white was quite uppity. Which certainly described Mary Baker!

    Reply
  14. Jo–
    I first found the story of Princess Caraboo as a sidebar in a book about odd British bits of history. I was entranced, and got a kick out of the movie when it was made somewhat later. I even wrote a very fluffy novella called The Devil’s Spawn that was inspired by Princess Caraboo, only the mysterious Polynesia savage who turned up was the hero, who was desperate to get close to the only woman he’d ever loved, ten years after her father broke up the relationship. Fun. *G*
    Interesting about the white dresses! I didn’t remember the bit from Mansfield Park, but it does suggest the idea that for a working girl to wear white was quite uppity. Which certainly described Mary Baker!

    Reply
  15. Jo–
    I first found the story of Princess Caraboo as a sidebar in a book about odd British bits of history. I was entranced, and got a kick out of the movie when it was made somewhat later. I even wrote a very fluffy novella called The Devil’s Spawn that was inspired by Princess Caraboo, only the mysterious Polynesia savage who turned up was the hero, who was desperate to get close to the only woman he’d ever loved, ten years after her father broke up the relationship. Fun. *G*
    Interesting about the white dresses! I didn’t remember the bit from Mansfield Park, but it does suggest the idea that for a working girl to wear white was quite uppity. Which certainly described Mary Baker!

    Reply
  16. This reminds me a bit of Suzanne Enoch’s Sins of a Duke. Looking at reviews, it seems a lot of people do think it’s unbelievable as fiction. Yet, if I remember correctly (which I might not be, since it’s been a while since I read it), she said in her author’s note that it was based on a true story.

    Reply
  17. This reminds me a bit of Suzanne Enoch’s Sins of a Duke. Looking at reviews, it seems a lot of people do think it’s unbelievable as fiction. Yet, if I remember correctly (which I might not be, since it’s been a while since I read it), she said in her author’s note that it was based on a true story.

    Reply
  18. This reminds me a bit of Suzanne Enoch’s Sins of a Duke. Looking at reviews, it seems a lot of people do think it’s unbelievable as fiction. Yet, if I remember correctly (which I might not be, since it’s been a while since I read it), she said in her author’s note that it was based on a true story.

    Reply
  19. This reminds me a bit of Suzanne Enoch’s Sins of a Duke. Looking at reviews, it seems a lot of people do think it’s unbelievable as fiction. Yet, if I remember correctly (which I might not be, since it’s been a while since I read it), she said in her author’s note that it was based on a true story.

    Reply
  20. This reminds me a bit of Suzanne Enoch’s Sins of a Duke. Looking at reviews, it seems a lot of people do think it’s unbelievable as fiction. Yet, if I remember correctly (which I might not be, since it’s been a while since I read it), she said in her author’s note that it was based on a true story.

    Reply
  21. The Princess Caraboo story appears in Amanda Scott’s The Battling Bluestocking, as Kara Boo in one of the several then current events discussed by the characters.
    I loved the movie too. One thing I liked about it was the touches of period accurate, if not especially appealing, details, such as some ladies’ painted faces and the stuff about teeth.

    Reply
  22. The Princess Caraboo story appears in Amanda Scott’s The Battling Bluestocking, as Kara Boo in one of the several then current events discussed by the characters.
    I loved the movie too. One thing I liked about it was the touches of period accurate, if not especially appealing, details, such as some ladies’ painted faces and the stuff about teeth.

    Reply
  23. The Princess Caraboo story appears in Amanda Scott’s The Battling Bluestocking, as Kara Boo in one of the several then current events discussed by the characters.
    I loved the movie too. One thing I liked about it was the touches of period accurate, if not especially appealing, details, such as some ladies’ painted faces and the stuff about teeth.

    Reply
  24. The Princess Caraboo story appears in Amanda Scott’s The Battling Bluestocking, as Kara Boo in one of the several then current events discussed by the characters.
    I loved the movie too. One thing I liked about it was the touches of period accurate, if not especially appealing, details, such as some ladies’ painted faces and the stuff about teeth.

    Reply
  25. The Princess Caraboo story appears in Amanda Scott’s The Battling Bluestocking, as Kara Boo in one of the several then current events discussed by the characters.
    I loved the movie too. One thing I liked about it was the touches of period accurate, if not especially appealing, details, such as some ladies’ painted faces and the stuff about teeth.

    Reply

Leave a Comment