On Scones (not biscuits)

Anne here, and today I'm talking about biscuits and scones. No, I'm not venturing into the territory where people with a death-wish will try to claim there is virtually no difference between English or Australian scones and US-style biscuits. (Been there, done that. Barely survived.) 36491431493_501442ae27_b

The inspiration for my post today came from the frustration of reading books where Regency-era folks sit down to afternoon tea with scones and jam and cream. And no, I'm not entering the debate about which goes on the scone first, the jam or the cream. Each to his own, say I. (Obviously IMO the jam should go first, but this image from Creative Commons is clearly hedging its bets.)

Now, "scone" is an old Scottish word, and according to the OED  a scone is "a large round cake made of wheat or barley-meal baked on a griddle."  And it's true that scones of various kinds have been made for centuries — potato scones, drop scones, griddle scones, and so on, but these were not like the scones in the photo above. They were generally some kind of batter that were baked on a stone or griddle or over a fire, and were more like a heavy pancake or a bready sort of cake. The leavening agent most used was buttermilk. Or yeast.

1600px-Scones_cream_jamScones as we know them, the sort in the yummy picture above, that are served with jam and cream, are generally made with flour, a little fat (usually butter), sometimes a little sugar (or not according to preference), liquid (generally milk or buttermilk) and a raising agent — bicarbonate of soda often with added cream of tartar, which is what we call baking powder today. (Though whoever served up these scones on the left is committing a scone no-no in my book. Can you tell what it is? I'll tell you at the end.)

The raising agent is a key ingredient, and during the Regency, the raising agents most people used in their baking were eggs or yeast or buttermilk. Because bicarbonate of soda had not yet been discovered/invented.

Though sodium bicabonate had been used as a leavening (raising) agent for many years, and was called soda ash by some, it was an English chemist and food manufacturer called Alfred Bird who developed the first baking powder, of the sort we know today, in 1843. 

He developed it because his wife was allergic to eggs and yeast, the traditional kinds of leavening agents, and was searching for an alternative for her. He mixed bicarbonate of soda and tartaric acid with starch to absorb moisture and prevent the other ingredients from reacting. He sold his product widely but didn't patent it and in 1845 Henry Jones of Bristol patented and widely sold a similar product, which he called "A new preparation of flour" that included sodium bicarbonate and tartaric acid to obtain a leavening effect. In other words, self-raising flour.
You can read more about the history of baking powder here.

1-afternoon-tea-george-goodwin-kilburneSo please, let's not have our regency-era people sitting down to scones and jam and cream. Cakes, yes, and biscuits (which in America are called cookies) and little tarts and curd cakes and teacakes and gingersnaps and more. But not scones.

I started getting deja-vu as I wrote some of this, and recalled (after I'd written most of the blog) that Mary Jo  had written a blog about scones five years ago. It's here, if you'd like to read it

I would disagree with her that an English-style scone is a "harder baked good that's more like a cracker or a cookie." My nana's scones were always soft and light, and so are most of the ones I've eaten or baked. Perhaps Mary Jo ate store bought or hotel scones. Or stale ones. They might have a slightly crisp outside when they come out of the oven, but they're soft inside. And if you wrap them in a tea-towel after baking, the outside is soft, too. And scones are best eaten fresh, straight out of the oven.

Here are some I baked earlier. Slightly burnt, I admit, and the one in the top left hand of the plate is the odd shape you get when you squish together the leftover bits of dough after you've cut out your neat round circles. And I didn't have any cream, but jam on its own with a bit of butter, or butter and honey is pretty delicious.1Scones

Have I tempted you to bake some scones? Here's a classic English scone recipe, a little fussier than my nana's, but very reliable. 

And here's a basic aussie scone recipe.

And lot of people I know bake what they call "lemonade scones" though there is not a sniff of lemon anywhere near them. "Lemonade" in Australia is plain sweet soda — like 7Up or Sprite. It's supposed to be very easy and foolproof, but I've never tried it. There's a recipe for lemonade scones here (and I'm closing my eyes to the shocking assertion that American biscuits and scones are the same thing!) 

And the scone no-no I referred to above?  Serving fruit scones with jam and cream! (gasp!) Nana would be horrified, I tell you. Fruit scones are served only with best butter! Or do you disagree?

Are you a fan of scones? Do you enjoy a Devonshire or cream tea (scones with jam and cream)? Or do you prefer savory treats? What kind of food do you serve if you have guests for afternoon tea?

210 thoughts on “On Scones (not biscuits)”

  1. I use that recipe from Annabele someone from NZ that you posted somewhere (vague, me?) where she barely touches the butter with her hands just uses a knife to mix. And I very roughly pull the dough into a round and cut them into rough shapes with the knife. They always come out looking a bit wonky but taste delicious. I always have one hot scone with thick butter only and the other with jam and cream, preferably raspberry.

    Reply
  2. I use that recipe from Annabele someone from NZ that you posted somewhere (vague, me?) where she barely touches the butter with her hands just uses a knife to mix. And I very roughly pull the dough into a round and cut them into rough shapes with the knife. They always come out looking a bit wonky but taste delicious. I always have one hot scone with thick butter only and the other with jam and cream, preferably raspberry.

    Reply
  3. I use that recipe from Annabele someone from NZ that you posted somewhere (vague, me?) where she barely touches the butter with her hands just uses a knife to mix. And I very roughly pull the dough into a round and cut them into rough shapes with the knife. They always come out looking a bit wonky but taste delicious. I always have one hot scone with thick butter only and the other with jam and cream, preferably raspberry.

    Reply
  4. I use that recipe from Annabele someone from NZ that you posted somewhere (vague, me?) where she barely touches the butter with her hands just uses a knife to mix. And I very roughly pull the dough into a round and cut them into rough shapes with the knife. They always come out looking a bit wonky but taste delicious. I always have one hot scone with thick butter only and the other with jam and cream, preferably raspberry.

    Reply
  5. I use that recipe from Annabele someone from NZ that you posted somewhere (vague, me?) where she barely touches the butter with her hands just uses a knife to mix. And I very roughly pull the dough into a round and cut them into rough shapes with the knife. They always come out looking a bit wonky but taste delicious. I always have one hot scone with thick butter only and the other with jam and cream, preferably raspberry.

    Reply
  6. My aunt, who was a farmer’s wife and often cooking morning or afternoon teas for shearers, etc. turned out scones very quickly and she always grated the butter into the flour (cooking butter). This made it easier to mix into the flour without handling it too much, resulting in a softer scone.

    Reply
  7. My aunt, who was a farmer’s wife and often cooking morning or afternoon teas for shearers, etc. turned out scones very quickly and she always grated the butter into the flour (cooking butter). This made it easier to mix into the flour without handling it too much, resulting in a softer scone.

    Reply
  8. My aunt, who was a farmer’s wife and often cooking morning or afternoon teas for shearers, etc. turned out scones very quickly and she always grated the butter into the flour (cooking butter). This made it easier to mix into the flour without handling it too much, resulting in a softer scone.

    Reply
  9. My aunt, who was a farmer’s wife and often cooking morning or afternoon teas for shearers, etc. turned out scones very quickly and she always grated the butter into the flour (cooking butter). This made it easier to mix into the flour without handling it too much, resulting in a softer scone.

    Reply
  10. My aunt, who was a farmer’s wife and often cooking morning or afternoon teas for shearers, etc. turned out scones very quickly and she always grated the butter into the flour (cooking butter). This made it easier to mix into the flour without handling it too much, resulting in a softer scone.

    Reply
  11. My nana never rolled her dough. After kneading she spread it out with her fingers and cut it into triangular shapes (reworking any odd bits of dough – if there were any – into each other). She usually got a dozen out of the mix.

    Reply
  12. My nana never rolled her dough. After kneading she spread it out with her fingers and cut it into triangular shapes (reworking any odd bits of dough – if there were any – into each other). She usually got a dozen out of the mix.

    Reply
  13. My nana never rolled her dough. After kneading she spread it out with her fingers and cut it into triangular shapes (reworking any odd bits of dough – if there were any – into each other). She usually got a dozen out of the mix.

    Reply
  14. My nana never rolled her dough. After kneading she spread it out with her fingers and cut it into triangular shapes (reworking any odd bits of dough – if there were any – into each other). She usually got a dozen out of the mix.

    Reply
  15. My nana never rolled her dough. After kneading she spread it out with her fingers and cut it into triangular shapes (reworking any odd bits of dough – if there were any – into each other). She usually got a dozen out of the mix.

    Reply
  16. Yes, Deb, I think the colder everything stays and the less the scone dough is handled the lighter the scones. I have used my food processor to whizz up some scone dough and it’s great.
    I guess that’s one of the differences between scones and American biscuits — the kneading and the folding that are done with the US biscuits.
    And I do like your butter and honey while it’s hot and later raspberry jam and cream. Yum yum.

    Reply
  17. Yes, Deb, I think the colder everything stays and the less the scone dough is handled the lighter the scones. I have used my food processor to whizz up some scone dough and it’s great.
    I guess that’s one of the differences between scones and American biscuits — the kneading and the folding that are done with the US biscuits.
    And I do like your butter and honey while it’s hot and later raspberry jam and cream. Yum yum.

    Reply
  18. Yes, Deb, I think the colder everything stays and the less the scone dough is handled the lighter the scones. I have used my food processor to whizz up some scone dough and it’s great.
    I guess that’s one of the differences between scones and American biscuits — the kneading and the folding that are done with the US biscuits.
    And I do like your butter and honey while it’s hot and later raspberry jam and cream. Yum yum.

    Reply
  19. Yes, Deb, I think the colder everything stays and the less the scone dough is handled the lighter the scones. I have used my food processor to whizz up some scone dough and it’s great.
    I guess that’s one of the differences between scones and American biscuits — the kneading and the folding that are done with the US biscuits.
    And I do like your butter and honey while it’s hot and later raspberry jam and cream. Yum yum.

    Reply
  20. Yes, Deb, I think the colder everything stays and the less the scone dough is handled the lighter the scones. I have used my food processor to whizz up some scone dough and it’s great.
    I guess that’s one of the differences between scones and American biscuits — the kneading and the folding that are done with the US biscuits.
    And I do like your butter and honey while it’s hot and later raspberry jam and cream. Yum yum.

    Reply
  21. Emily yes, I know a few people who grate the butter in, and I’m sure it works really well. As I said to Deb (above) the less the dough is handled the better.
    Actually Helen Bianchin once told me the secret of making gnocchi — she said “Treat it like scones. The less the mix is handed the better.” And since then it’s how I make my gnocchi.
    I’m sure your aunt has lots of great tips and tricks — cooking for shearers is no picnic.

    Reply
  22. Emily yes, I know a few people who grate the butter in, and I’m sure it works really well. As I said to Deb (above) the less the dough is handled the better.
    Actually Helen Bianchin once told me the secret of making gnocchi — she said “Treat it like scones. The less the mix is handed the better.” And since then it’s how I make my gnocchi.
    I’m sure your aunt has lots of great tips and tricks — cooking for shearers is no picnic.

    Reply
  23. Emily yes, I know a few people who grate the butter in, and I’m sure it works really well. As I said to Deb (above) the less the dough is handled the better.
    Actually Helen Bianchin once told me the secret of making gnocchi — she said “Treat it like scones. The less the mix is handed the better.” And since then it’s how I make my gnocchi.
    I’m sure your aunt has lots of great tips and tricks — cooking for shearers is no picnic.

    Reply
  24. Emily yes, I know a few people who grate the butter in, and I’m sure it works really well. As I said to Deb (above) the less the dough is handled the better.
    Actually Helen Bianchin once told me the secret of making gnocchi — she said “Treat it like scones. The less the mix is handed the better.” And since then it’s how I make my gnocchi.
    I’m sure your aunt has lots of great tips and tricks — cooking for shearers is no picnic.

    Reply
  25. Emily yes, I know a few people who grate the butter in, and I’m sure it works really well. As I said to Deb (above) the less the dough is handled the better.
    Actually Helen Bianchin once told me the secret of making gnocchi — she said “Treat it like scones. The less the mix is handed the better.” And since then it’s how I make my gnocchi.
    I’m sure your aunt has lots of great tips and tricks — cooking for shearers is no picnic.

    Reply
  26. Thanks, Vicki, yes I often just pat it down — unless I’m aiming for neater scones. Nana made her date scones a bit like yours, though they were always square-ish. And they were delicious.

    Reply
  27. Thanks, Vicki, yes I often just pat it down — unless I’m aiming for neater scones. Nana made her date scones a bit like yours, though they were always square-ish. And they were delicious.

    Reply
  28. Thanks, Vicki, yes I often just pat it down — unless I’m aiming for neater scones. Nana made her date scones a bit like yours, though they were always square-ish. And they were delicious.

    Reply
  29. Thanks, Vicki, yes I often just pat it down — unless I’m aiming for neater scones. Nana made her date scones a bit like yours, though they were always square-ish. And they were delicious.

    Reply
  30. Thanks, Vicki, yes I often just pat it down — unless I’m aiming for neater scones. Nana made her date scones a bit like yours, though they were always square-ish. And they were delicious.

    Reply
  31. My grandmother turned out lovely scones. Light and airy on the inside and nicely crisped on the out. I was instructed as a small child to spread the jam carefully and then, a dollop of cream to top them off. I always liked the cream part 😉
    My mother was not a baker and so, my grandmother’s recipe is lost to time 🙁 I wish I had it. I miss those scones.

    Reply
  32. My grandmother turned out lovely scones. Light and airy on the inside and nicely crisped on the out. I was instructed as a small child to spread the jam carefully and then, a dollop of cream to top them off. I always liked the cream part 😉
    My mother was not a baker and so, my grandmother’s recipe is lost to time 🙁 I wish I had it. I miss those scones.

    Reply
  33. My grandmother turned out lovely scones. Light and airy on the inside and nicely crisped on the out. I was instructed as a small child to spread the jam carefully and then, a dollop of cream to top them off. I always liked the cream part 😉
    My mother was not a baker and so, my grandmother’s recipe is lost to time 🙁 I wish I had it. I miss those scones.

    Reply
  34. My grandmother turned out lovely scones. Light and airy on the inside and nicely crisped on the out. I was instructed as a small child to spread the jam carefully and then, a dollop of cream to top them off. I always liked the cream part 😉
    My mother was not a baker and so, my grandmother’s recipe is lost to time 🙁 I wish I had it. I miss those scones.

    Reply
  35. My grandmother turned out lovely scones. Light and airy on the inside and nicely crisped on the out. I was instructed as a small child to spread the jam carefully and then, a dollop of cream to top them off. I always liked the cream part 😉
    My mother was not a baker and so, my grandmother’s recipe is lost to time 🙁 I wish I had it. I miss those scones.

    Reply
  36. The best ‘cream tea’ I’ve ever had was in Cornwall many years ago. The clotted cream was solid, but softened on the warm scones. I’d eat them any way, cream or jam first makes no difference to me!
    Reading you has tempted me to make scones, but they don’t have clotted cream in France, I’m afraid.

    Reply
  37. The best ‘cream tea’ I’ve ever had was in Cornwall many years ago. The clotted cream was solid, but softened on the warm scones. I’d eat them any way, cream or jam first makes no difference to me!
    Reading you has tempted me to make scones, but they don’t have clotted cream in France, I’m afraid.

    Reply
  38. The best ‘cream tea’ I’ve ever had was in Cornwall many years ago. The clotted cream was solid, but softened on the warm scones. I’d eat them any way, cream or jam first makes no difference to me!
    Reading you has tempted me to make scones, but they don’t have clotted cream in France, I’m afraid.

    Reply
  39. The best ‘cream tea’ I’ve ever had was in Cornwall many years ago. The clotted cream was solid, but softened on the warm scones. I’d eat them any way, cream or jam first makes no difference to me!
    Reading you has tempted me to make scones, but they don’t have clotted cream in France, I’m afraid.

    Reply
  40. The best ‘cream tea’ I’ve ever had was in Cornwall many years ago. The clotted cream was solid, but softened on the warm scones. I’d eat them any way, cream or jam first makes no difference to me!
    Reading you has tempted me to make scones, but they don’t have clotted cream in France, I’m afraid.

    Reply
  41. My mum made wheaten scones: I don’t have the recipe, but I have the memory. Always eaten still hot from the oven, and slathered with butter.
    I could never bake nice-tasting scones until someone I worked with, whose scones are lovely, told me to use soda bread flour and buttermilk. (Google Jenny Bristow’s recipe for amounts.) I don’t make them often, but they do seem to always work.

    Reply
  42. My mum made wheaten scones: I don’t have the recipe, but I have the memory. Always eaten still hot from the oven, and slathered with butter.
    I could never bake nice-tasting scones until someone I worked with, whose scones are lovely, told me to use soda bread flour and buttermilk. (Google Jenny Bristow’s recipe for amounts.) I don’t make them often, but they do seem to always work.

    Reply
  43. My mum made wheaten scones: I don’t have the recipe, but I have the memory. Always eaten still hot from the oven, and slathered with butter.
    I could never bake nice-tasting scones until someone I worked with, whose scones are lovely, told me to use soda bread flour and buttermilk. (Google Jenny Bristow’s recipe for amounts.) I don’t make them often, but they do seem to always work.

    Reply
  44. My mum made wheaten scones: I don’t have the recipe, but I have the memory. Always eaten still hot from the oven, and slathered with butter.
    I could never bake nice-tasting scones until someone I worked with, whose scones are lovely, told me to use soda bread flour and buttermilk. (Google Jenny Bristow’s recipe for amounts.) I don’t make them often, but they do seem to always work.

    Reply
  45. My mum made wheaten scones: I don’t have the recipe, but I have the memory. Always eaten still hot from the oven, and slathered with butter.
    I could never bake nice-tasting scones until someone I worked with, whose scones are lovely, told me to use soda bread flour and buttermilk. (Google Jenny Bristow’s recipe for amounts.) I don’t make them often, but they do seem to always work.

    Reply
  46. I used to make very good American biscuits, but I haven’t succeeded in making scones, although I have a recipe or two from British books I bought on my oft mentioned short tour.
    I can buy very good scones from a national restaurant called Panera, and I often do. We tend to eat them with butter, but those particular scones come iced, which may be a no-no. Otherwise they are quite good, and close to what I had a Stonehenge.

    Reply
  47. I used to make very good American biscuits, but I haven’t succeeded in making scones, although I have a recipe or two from British books I bought on my oft mentioned short tour.
    I can buy very good scones from a national restaurant called Panera, and I often do. We tend to eat them with butter, but those particular scones come iced, which may be a no-no. Otherwise they are quite good, and close to what I had a Stonehenge.

    Reply
  48. I used to make very good American biscuits, but I haven’t succeeded in making scones, although I have a recipe or two from British books I bought on my oft mentioned short tour.
    I can buy very good scones from a national restaurant called Panera, and I often do. We tend to eat them with butter, but those particular scones come iced, which may be a no-no. Otherwise they are quite good, and close to what I had a Stonehenge.

    Reply
  49. I used to make very good American biscuits, but I haven’t succeeded in making scones, although I have a recipe or two from British books I bought on my oft mentioned short tour.
    I can buy very good scones from a national restaurant called Panera, and I often do. We tend to eat them with butter, but those particular scones come iced, which may be a no-no. Otherwise they are quite good, and close to what I had a Stonehenge.

    Reply
  50. I used to make very good American biscuits, but I haven’t succeeded in making scones, although I have a recipe or two from British books I bought on my oft mentioned short tour.
    I can buy very good scones from a national restaurant called Panera, and I often do. We tend to eat them with butter, but those particular scones come iced, which may be a no-no. Otherwise they are quite good, and close to what I had a Stonehenge.

    Reply
  51. This is one of many things I got wrong in early books, and my dad was a food scientist (also, modern scones are really good). I looked up the provenance of the word, saw recipes dating back to the 1500s, and away I went, troweling on the cream and jam. I also served Indian tea varieties about twenty years too soon, but fortunately, readers straightened me out. (Buh-bye, Assam…)
    Wish I’d read your lovely blog post much earlier (but really, a life without scones? Really?)….

    Reply
  52. This is one of many things I got wrong in early books, and my dad was a food scientist (also, modern scones are really good). I looked up the provenance of the word, saw recipes dating back to the 1500s, and away I went, troweling on the cream and jam. I also served Indian tea varieties about twenty years too soon, but fortunately, readers straightened me out. (Buh-bye, Assam…)
    Wish I’d read your lovely blog post much earlier (but really, a life without scones? Really?)….

    Reply
  53. This is one of many things I got wrong in early books, and my dad was a food scientist (also, modern scones are really good). I looked up the provenance of the word, saw recipes dating back to the 1500s, and away I went, troweling on the cream and jam. I also served Indian tea varieties about twenty years too soon, but fortunately, readers straightened me out. (Buh-bye, Assam…)
    Wish I’d read your lovely blog post much earlier (but really, a life without scones? Really?)….

    Reply
  54. This is one of many things I got wrong in early books, and my dad was a food scientist (also, modern scones are really good). I looked up the provenance of the word, saw recipes dating back to the 1500s, and away I went, troweling on the cream and jam. I also served Indian tea varieties about twenty years too soon, but fortunately, readers straightened me out. (Buh-bye, Assam…)
    Wish I’d read your lovely blog post much earlier (but really, a life without scones? Really?)….

    Reply
  55. This is one of many things I got wrong in early books, and my dad was a food scientist (also, modern scones are really good). I looked up the provenance of the word, saw recipes dating back to the 1500s, and away I went, troweling on the cream and jam. I also served Indian tea varieties about twenty years too soon, but fortunately, readers straightened me out. (Buh-bye, Assam…)
    Wish I’d read your lovely blog post much earlier (but really, a life without scones? Really?)….

    Reply
  56. Wow I love ❤️ 💕 💗 this post! Cooking and the history of it is fascinating to me, you gave me so much delicious knowledge, and your personal scone take is super cool too. Thanks for it!
    Me, don’t love them, but admit one cream tea in England on a sunny day Norfolk changed me mind on tea and scones. In the right conditions, the bland dry scone is a perfect platter for jam and cream, and the tea to wash it down was… the first time I enjoyed tea, like, ever.
    Thanks again for a VERY excellent post.

    Reply
  57. Wow I love ❤️ 💕 💗 this post! Cooking and the history of it is fascinating to me, you gave me so much delicious knowledge, and your personal scone take is super cool too. Thanks for it!
    Me, don’t love them, but admit one cream tea in England on a sunny day Norfolk changed me mind on tea and scones. In the right conditions, the bland dry scone is a perfect platter for jam and cream, and the tea to wash it down was… the first time I enjoyed tea, like, ever.
    Thanks again for a VERY excellent post.

    Reply
  58. Wow I love ❤️ 💕 💗 this post! Cooking and the history of it is fascinating to me, you gave me so much delicious knowledge, and your personal scone take is super cool too. Thanks for it!
    Me, don’t love them, but admit one cream tea in England on a sunny day Norfolk changed me mind on tea and scones. In the right conditions, the bland dry scone is a perfect platter for jam and cream, and the tea to wash it down was… the first time I enjoyed tea, like, ever.
    Thanks again for a VERY excellent post.

    Reply
  59. Wow I love ❤️ 💕 💗 this post! Cooking and the history of it is fascinating to me, you gave me so much delicious knowledge, and your personal scone take is super cool too. Thanks for it!
    Me, don’t love them, but admit one cream tea in England on a sunny day Norfolk changed me mind on tea and scones. In the right conditions, the bland dry scone is a perfect platter for jam and cream, and the tea to wash it down was… the first time I enjoyed tea, like, ever.
    Thanks again for a VERY excellent post.

    Reply
  60. Wow I love ❤️ 💕 💗 this post! Cooking and the history of it is fascinating to me, you gave me so much delicious knowledge, and your personal scone take is super cool too. Thanks for it!
    Me, don’t love them, but admit one cream tea in England on a sunny day Norfolk changed me mind on tea and scones. In the right conditions, the bland dry scone is a perfect platter for jam and cream, and the tea to wash it down was… the first time I enjoyed tea, like, ever.
    Thanks again for a VERY excellent post.

    Reply
  61. I would happily eat scones any way I could get them, with or without the approval of custom, but all baked goods are now off the diet plan due to a severe wheat reaction. Gluten free options do their darnedest, but it’s just not the same. I used to make scones with sour cream as per a popular recipe (claiming kinship with the original Savoy Hotel’s scones) on allrecipes dotcom. They were sublime!

    Reply
  62. I would happily eat scones any way I could get them, with or without the approval of custom, but all baked goods are now off the diet plan due to a severe wheat reaction. Gluten free options do their darnedest, but it’s just not the same. I used to make scones with sour cream as per a popular recipe (claiming kinship with the original Savoy Hotel’s scones) on allrecipes dotcom. They were sublime!

    Reply
  63. I would happily eat scones any way I could get them, with or without the approval of custom, but all baked goods are now off the diet plan due to a severe wheat reaction. Gluten free options do their darnedest, but it’s just not the same. I used to make scones with sour cream as per a popular recipe (claiming kinship with the original Savoy Hotel’s scones) on allrecipes dotcom. They were sublime!

    Reply
  64. I would happily eat scones any way I could get them, with or without the approval of custom, but all baked goods are now off the diet plan due to a severe wheat reaction. Gluten free options do their darnedest, but it’s just not the same. I used to make scones with sour cream as per a popular recipe (claiming kinship with the original Savoy Hotel’s scones) on allrecipes dotcom. They were sublime!

    Reply
  65. I would happily eat scones any way I could get them, with or without the approval of custom, but all baked goods are now off the diet plan due to a severe wheat reaction. Gluten free options do their darnedest, but it’s just not the same. I used to make scones with sour cream as per a popular recipe (claiming kinship with the original Savoy Hotel’s scones) on allrecipes dotcom. They were sublime!

    Reply
  66. Thank you for this article, Anne. I’ve been annoyed over and over again by scones appearing long before they should. And by people inviting guests to afternoon tea long before it was a thing. But food and meals are always a problem.
    Then there are the scones I sometimes see in bakeries which are nothing like the scones I’ve had in England, but are big, lumpy things full of dried fruits and nuts and chocolate chips. I think they’re really rock cakes. *G*
    I sometimes think that we, especially we Americans, have a picture of Edwardian England and think it applies to everything after the Tudors.

    Reply
  67. Thank you for this article, Anne. I’ve been annoyed over and over again by scones appearing long before they should. And by people inviting guests to afternoon tea long before it was a thing. But food and meals are always a problem.
    Then there are the scones I sometimes see in bakeries which are nothing like the scones I’ve had in England, but are big, lumpy things full of dried fruits and nuts and chocolate chips. I think they’re really rock cakes. *G*
    I sometimes think that we, especially we Americans, have a picture of Edwardian England and think it applies to everything after the Tudors.

    Reply
  68. Thank you for this article, Anne. I’ve been annoyed over and over again by scones appearing long before they should. And by people inviting guests to afternoon tea long before it was a thing. But food and meals are always a problem.
    Then there are the scones I sometimes see in bakeries which are nothing like the scones I’ve had in England, but are big, lumpy things full of dried fruits and nuts and chocolate chips. I think they’re really rock cakes. *G*
    I sometimes think that we, especially we Americans, have a picture of Edwardian England and think it applies to everything after the Tudors.

    Reply
  69. Thank you for this article, Anne. I’ve been annoyed over and over again by scones appearing long before they should. And by people inviting guests to afternoon tea long before it was a thing. But food and meals are always a problem.
    Then there are the scones I sometimes see in bakeries which are nothing like the scones I’ve had in England, but are big, lumpy things full of dried fruits and nuts and chocolate chips. I think they’re really rock cakes. *G*
    I sometimes think that we, especially we Americans, have a picture of Edwardian England and think it applies to everything after the Tudors.

    Reply
  70. Thank you for this article, Anne. I’ve been annoyed over and over again by scones appearing long before they should. And by people inviting guests to afternoon tea long before it was a thing. But food and meals are always a problem.
    Then there are the scones I sometimes see in bakeries which are nothing like the scones I’ve had in England, but are big, lumpy things full of dried fruits and nuts and chocolate chips. I think they’re really rock cakes. *G*
    I sometimes think that we, especially we Americans, have a picture of Edwardian England and think it applies to everything after the Tudors.

    Reply
  71. I grew up in Australia and that was my first encounter with scones — yum! There were also pikelets and cream horns and…. Now I’m getting hungry. Thanks for a fun post, Anne.

    Reply
  72. I grew up in Australia and that was my first encounter with scones — yum! There were also pikelets and cream horns and…. Now I’m getting hungry. Thanks for a fun post, Anne.

    Reply
  73. I grew up in Australia and that was my first encounter with scones — yum! There were also pikelets and cream horns and…. Now I’m getting hungry. Thanks for a fun post, Anne.

    Reply
  74. I grew up in Australia and that was my first encounter with scones — yum! There were also pikelets and cream horns and…. Now I’m getting hungry. Thanks for a fun post, Anne.

    Reply
  75. I grew up in Australia and that was my first encounter with scones — yum! There were also pikelets and cream horns and…. Now I’m getting hungry. Thanks for a fun post, Anne.

    Reply
  76. I’ll say up front that I’m American so that has affected my perception of scones. Though I have to agree that some of the scones I see in the store are NOTHING like any scones I’ve ever made.
    One of the best scones I ever ate my husband bought while we were waiting for a ferry on Vancouver Island in Cnanada. Oh my gosh was it good. Light. Airy. SOOO good. It did have fresh raspberries in it.
    I will have to try lemonade scones when my mother is back home. She and I love love scones. We went on a scone experimenting binge back in 2006/2007 after she went to England. I’ve made savory and sweet scones
    One kind I made is a mint chocolate chip scone which is THE favorite of several of my friends. Me…I like all kinds.
    As for biscuits, unlike Sue McCormick (comments above) do that well with them. I’m much better at making scones. You would think if I could do one I could do the other. Apparently not.
    Thanks to everyone for the recipe links as well!

    Reply
  77. I’ll say up front that I’m American so that has affected my perception of scones. Though I have to agree that some of the scones I see in the store are NOTHING like any scones I’ve ever made.
    One of the best scones I ever ate my husband bought while we were waiting for a ferry on Vancouver Island in Cnanada. Oh my gosh was it good. Light. Airy. SOOO good. It did have fresh raspberries in it.
    I will have to try lemonade scones when my mother is back home. She and I love love scones. We went on a scone experimenting binge back in 2006/2007 after she went to England. I’ve made savory and sweet scones
    One kind I made is a mint chocolate chip scone which is THE favorite of several of my friends. Me…I like all kinds.
    As for biscuits, unlike Sue McCormick (comments above) do that well with them. I’m much better at making scones. You would think if I could do one I could do the other. Apparently not.
    Thanks to everyone for the recipe links as well!

    Reply
  78. I’ll say up front that I’m American so that has affected my perception of scones. Though I have to agree that some of the scones I see in the store are NOTHING like any scones I’ve ever made.
    One of the best scones I ever ate my husband bought while we were waiting for a ferry on Vancouver Island in Cnanada. Oh my gosh was it good. Light. Airy. SOOO good. It did have fresh raspberries in it.
    I will have to try lemonade scones when my mother is back home. She and I love love scones. We went on a scone experimenting binge back in 2006/2007 after she went to England. I’ve made savory and sweet scones
    One kind I made is a mint chocolate chip scone which is THE favorite of several of my friends. Me…I like all kinds.
    As for biscuits, unlike Sue McCormick (comments above) do that well with them. I’m much better at making scones. You would think if I could do one I could do the other. Apparently not.
    Thanks to everyone for the recipe links as well!

    Reply
  79. I’ll say up front that I’m American so that has affected my perception of scones. Though I have to agree that some of the scones I see in the store are NOTHING like any scones I’ve ever made.
    One of the best scones I ever ate my husband bought while we were waiting for a ferry on Vancouver Island in Cnanada. Oh my gosh was it good. Light. Airy. SOOO good. It did have fresh raspberries in it.
    I will have to try lemonade scones when my mother is back home. She and I love love scones. We went on a scone experimenting binge back in 2006/2007 after she went to England. I’ve made savory and sweet scones
    One kind I made is a mint chocolate chip scone which is THE favorite of several of my friends. Me…I like all kinds.
    As for biscuits, unlike Sue McCormick (comments above) do that well with them. I’m much better at making scones. You would think if I could do one I could do the other. Apparently not.
    Thanks to everyone for the recipe links as well!

    Reply
  80. I’ll say up front that I’m American so that has affected my perception of scones. Though I have to agree that some of the scones I see in the store are NOTHING like any scones I’ve ever made.
    One of the best scones I ever ate my husband bought while we were waiting for a ferry on Vancouver Island in Cnanada. Oh my gosh was it good. Light. Airy. SOOO good. It did have fresh raspberries in it.
    I will have to try lemonade scones when my mother is back home. She and I love love scones. We went on a scone experimenting binge back in 2006/2007 after she went to England. I’ve made savory and sweet scones
    One kind I made is a mint chocolate chip scone which is THE favorite of several of my friends. Me…I like all kinds.
    As for biscuits, unlike Sue McCormick (comments above) do that well with them. I’m much better at making scones. You would think if I could do one I could do the other. Apparently not.
    Thanks to everyone for the recipe links as well!

    Reply
  81. Theo, scones are pretty easy to make. Just don’t overwork them.
    I’m planning to try “lemonade” scones. They’re supposed to be easy and very good. I haven’t yet, because I tend to only make scones when I am expecting visitors, and I don’t want to try a new recipe in case it doesn’t work out. When I had a day job I used to experiment with all kinds of recipes and take the results to work for people to eat. Now, being a full-time writer, there’s only me and the dog to eat them — which is dangerous.

    Reply
  82. Theo, scones are pretty easy to make. Just don’t overwork them.
    I’m planning to try “lemonade” scones. They’re supposed to be easy and very good. I haven’t yet, because I tend to only make scones when I am expecting visitors, and I don’t want to try a new recipe in case it doesn’t work out. When I had a day job I used to experiment with all kinds of recipes and take the results to work for people to eat. Now, being a full-time writer, there’s only me and the dog to eat them — which is dangerous.

    Reply
  83. Theo, scones are pretty easy to make. Just don’t overwork them.
    I’m planning to try “lemonade” scones. They’re supposed to be easy and very good. I haven’t yet, because I tend to only make scones when I am expecting visitors, and I don’t want to try a new recipe in case it doesn’t work out. When I had a day job I used to experiment with all kinds of recipes and take the results to work for people to eat. Now, being a full-time writer, there’s only me and the dog to eat them — which is dangerous.

    Reply
  84. Theo, scones are pretty easy to make. Just don’t overwork them.
    I’m planning to try “lemonade” scones. They’re supposed to be easy and very good. I haven’t yet, because I tend to only make scones when I am expecting visitors, and I don’t want to try a new recipe in case it doesn’t work out. When I had a day job I used to experiment with all kinds of recipes and take the results to work for people to eat. Now, being a full-time writer, there’s only me and the dog to eat them — which is dangerous.

    Reply
  85. Theo, scones are pretty easy to make. Just don’t overwork them.
    I’m planning to try “lemonade” scones. They’re supposed to be easy and very good. I haven’t yet, because I tend to only make scones when I am expecting visitors, and I don’t want to try a new recipe in case it doesn’t work out. When I had a day job I used to experiment with all kinds of recipes and take the results to work for people to eat. Now, being a full-time writer, there’s only me and the dog to eat them — which is dangerous.

    Reply
  86. Suzy, I’ve never seen clotted cream here in Australia, either. In fact when the wenches were talking about these matters, back when the discussion resulted in Mary Jo’s scone post, I remember she was shocked that I’d never had clotted cream. But we have lovely thick fresh cream, so I’m not repining.

    Reply
  87. Suzy, I’ve never seen clotted cream here in Australia, either. In fact when the wenches were talking about these matters, back when the discussion resulted in Mary Jo’s scone post, I remember she was shocked that I’d never had clotted cream. But we have lovely thick fresh cream, so I’m not repining.

    Reply
  88. Suzy, I’ve never seen clotted cream here in Australia, either. In fact when the wenches were talking about these matters, back when the discussion resulted in Mary Jo’s scone post, I remember she was shocked that I’d never had clotted cream. But we have lovely thick fresh cream, so I’m not repining.

    Reply
  89. Suzy, I’ve never seen clotted cream here in Australia, either. In fact when the wenches were talking about these matters, back when the discussion resulted in Mary Jo’s scone post, I remember she was shocked that I’d never had clotted cream. But we have lovely thick fresh cream, so I’m not repining.

    Reply
  90. Suzy, I’ve never seen clotted cream here in Australia, either. In fact when the wenches were talking about these matters, back when the discussion resulted in Mary Jo’s scone post, I remember she was shocked that I’d never had clotted cream. But we have lovely thick fresh cream, so I’m not repining.

    Reply
  91. Yes, buttermilk is supposed to make scones lighter. Thanks for that suggestion. I’m not sure we have special soda bread flour. I use ordinary flour or if I have it, bread flour. So many special kinds of flours these days.

    Reply
  92. Yes, buttermilk is supposed to make scones lighter. Thanks for that suggestion. I’m not sure we have special soda bread flour. I use ordinary flour or if I have it, bread flour. So many special kinds of flours these days.

    Reply
  93. Yes, buttermilk is supposed to make scones lighter. Thanks for that suggestion. I’m not sure we have special soda bread flour. I use ordinary flour or if I have it, bread flour. So many special kinds of flours these days.

    Reply
  94. Yes, buttermilk is supposed to make scones lighter. Thanks for that suggestion. I’m not sure we have special soda bread flour. I use ordinary flour or if I have it, bread flour. So many special kinds of flours these days.

    Reply
  95. Yes, buttermilk is supposed to make scones lighter. Thanks for that suggestion. I’m not sure we have special soda bread flour. I use ordinary flour or if I have it, bread flour. So many special kinds of flours these days.

    Reply
  96. Yes, a wee bit pricey, Mary Jo. I would bake scones every day, they’re so easy — but then I’d eat them, and slathered with jam and cream (or butter and honey while hot) . . .well, they wouldn’t do me any good. But I might try baking some of those lemonade scones and take them around to a friend’s place. I’ll let you know how it goes.

    Reply
  97. Yes, a wee bit pricey, Mary Jo. I would bake scones every day, they’re so easy — but then I’d eat them, and slathered with jam and cream (or butter and honey while hot) . . .well, they wouldn’t do me any good. But I might try baking some of those lemonade scones and take them around to a friend’s place. I’ll let you know how it goes.

    Reply
  98. Yes, a wee bit pricey, Mary Jo. I would bake scones every day, they’re so easy — but then I’d eat them, and slathered with jam and cream (or butter and honey while hot) . . .well, they wouldn’t do me any good. But I might try baking some of those lemonade scones and take them around to a friend’s place. I’ll let you know how it goes.

    Reply
  99. Yes, a wee bit pricey, Mary Jo. I would bake scones every day, they’re so easy — but then I’d eat them, and slathered with jam and cream (or butter and honey while hot) . . .well, they wouldn’t do me any good. But I might try baking some of those lemonade scones and take them around to a friend’s place. I’ll let you know how it goes.

    Reply
  100. Yes, a wee bit pricey, Mary Jo. I would bake scones every day, they’re so easy — but then I’d eat them, and slathered with jam and cream (or butter and honey while hot) . . .well, they wouldn’t do me any good. But I might try baking some of those lemonade scones and take them around to a friend’s place. I’ll let you know how it goes.

    Reply
  101. Sue, yes, iced would definitely be a no-no as far as Nan was concerned. Interesting that you can make biscuits but not scones — seems there’s more handling with biscuits. With scones you just barely bring the dough together — no kneading, otherwise they’re heavy and tough.

    Reply
  102. Sue, yes, iced would definitely be a no-no as far as Nan was concerned. Interesting that you can make biscuits but not scones — seems there’s more handling with biscuits. With scones you just barely bring the dough together — no kneading, otherwise they’re heavy and tough.

    Reply
  103. Sue, yes, iced would definitely be a no-no as far as Nan was concerned. Interesting that you can make biscuits but not scones — seems there’s more handling with biscuits. With scones you just barely bring the dough together — no kneading, otherwise they’re heavy and tough.

    Reply
  104. Sue, yes, iced would definitely be a no-no as far as Nan was concerned. Interesting that you can make biscuits but not scones — seems there’s more handling with biscuits. With scones you just barely bring the dough together — no kneading, otherwise they’re heavy and tough.

    Reply
  105. Sue, yes, iced would definitely be a no-no as far as Nan was concerned. Interesting that you can make biscuits but not scones — seems there’s more handling with biscuits. With scones you just barely bring the dough together — no kneading, otherwise they’re heavy and tough.

    Reply
  106. Yes, Grace — it’s annoying, isn’t it, that scones have been around for centuries, and when they invented baking powder they called them by the same name! Cheeky, I call it. And readers will usually straighten us out. I’ve made my share of historical bloopers. In my case they’re always the things I’m so sure of, I haven’t looked up.
    Thanks for dropping by.

    Reply
  107. Yes, Grace — it’s annoying, isn’t it, that scones have been around for centuries, and when they invented baking powder they called them by the same name! Cheeky, I call it. And readers will usually straighten us out. I’ve made my share of historical bloopers. In my case they’re always the things I’m so sure of, I haven’t looked up.
    Thanks for dropping by.

    Reply
  108. Yes, Grace — it’s annoying, isn’t it, that scones have been around for centuries, and when they invented baking powder they called them by the same name! Cheeky, I call it. And readers will usually straighten us out. I’ve made my share of historical bloopers. In my case they’re always the things I’m so sure of, I haven’t looked up.
    Thanks for dropping by.

    Reply
  109. Yes, Grace — it’s annoying, isn’t it, that scones have been around for centuries, and when they invented baking powder they called them by the same name! Cheeky, I call it. And readers will usually straighten us out. I’ve made my share of historical bloopers. In my case they’re always the things I’m so sure of, I haven’t looked up.
    Thanks for dropping by.

    Reply
  110. Yes, Grace — it’s annoying, isn’t it, that scones have been around for centuries, and when they invented baking powder they called them by the same name! Cheeky, I call it. And readers will usually straighten us out. I’ve made my share of historical bloopers. In my case they’re always the things I’m so sure of, I haven’t looked up.
    Thanks for dropping by.

    Reply
  111. Hi Susie. Yes, a plain dry scone is really nothing but a background for jam and cream or maybe butter and honey. Unless it has fruit in it. My nana made really delicious date scones which we spit and buttered.
    Scones are pretty standard fare downunder, I suppose because they’re so quick and easy to make.And we’re big on morning and afternoon tea here.
    Thanks for popping by.

    Reply
  112. Hi Susie. Yes, a plain dry scone is really nothing but a background for jam and cream or maybe butter and honey. Unless it has fruit in it. My nana made really delicious date scones which we spit and buttered.
    Scones are pretty standard fare downunder, I suppose because they’re so quick and easy to make.And we’re big on morning and afternoon tea here.
    Thanks for popping by.

    Reply
  113. Hi Susie. Yes, a plain dry scone is really nothing but a background for jam and cream or maybe butter and honey. Unless it has fruit in it. My nana made really delicious date scones which we spit and buttered.
    Scones are pretty standard fare downunder, I suppose because they’re so quick and easy to make.And we’re big on morning and afternoon tea here.
    Thanks for popping by.

    Reply
  114. Hi Susie. Yes, a plain dry scone is really nothing but a background for jam and cream or maybe butter and honey. Unless it has fruit in it. My nana made really delicious date scones which we spit and buttered.
    Scones are pretty standard fare downunder, I suppose because they’re so quick and easy to make.And we’re big on morning and afternoon tea here.
    Thanks for popping by.

    Reply
  115. Hi Susie. Yes, a plain dry scone is really nothing but a background for jam and cream or maybe butter and honey. Unless it has fruit in it. My nana made really delicious date scones which we spit and buttered.
    Scones are pretty standard fare downunder, I suppose because they’re so quick and easy to make.And we’re big on morning and afternoon tea here.
    Thanks for popping by.

    Reply
  116. Jenny what a shame about the wheat allergy. I think my friend Keri has a wheat-free alternative — not sure. I know she’s allergic now, but she used to be famed for her scones. I’ll ask her.
    I’ve never made scones with sour cream, but I’m sure it would be delicious.

    Reply
  117. Jenny what a shame about the wheat allergy. I think my friend Keri has a wheat-free alternative — not sure. I know she’s allergic now, but she used to be famed for her scones. I’ll ask her.
    I’ve never made scones with sour cream, but I’m sure it would be delicious.

    Reply
  118. Jenny what a shame about the wheat allergy. I think my friend Keri has a wheat-free alternative — not sure. I know she’s allergic now, but she used to be famed for her scones. I’ll ask her.
    I’ve never made scones with sour cream, but I’m sure it would be delicious.

    Reply
  119. Jenny what a shame about the wheat allergy. I think my friend Keri has a wheat-free alternative — not sure. I know she’s allergic now, but she used to be famed for her scones. I’ll ask her.
    I’ve never made scones with sour cream, but I’m sure it would be delicious.

    Reply
  120. Jenny what a shame about the wheat allergy. I think my friend Keri has a wheat-free alternative — not sure. I know she’s allergic now, but she used to be famed for her scones. I’ll ask her.
    I’ve never made scones with sour cream, but I’m sure it would be delicious.

    Reply
  121. Lil, yes, for me (and nana) scones can have fruit like sultanas or currants or dates in them, but that’s about all. Certainly not nuts and chocolate chips. You’re right — I’d call them rock cakes. I think people sometimes don’t realize that the idea is to split the scones and add jam and cream or whatever — some people like marmalade, or lemon curd. But, each to his own.

    Reply
  122. Lil, yes, for me (and nana) scones can have fruit like sultanas or currants or dates in them, but that’s about all. Certainly not nuts and chocolate chips. You’re right — I’d call them rock cakes. I think people sometimes don’t realize that the idea is to split the scones and add jam and cream or whatever — some people like marmalade, or lemon curd. But, each to his own.

    Reply
  123. Lil, yes, for me (and nana) scones can have fruit like sultanas or currants or dates in them, but that’s about all. Certainly not nuts and chocolate chips. You’re right — I’d call them rock cakes. I think people sometimes don’t realize that the idea is to split the scones and add jam and cream or whatever — some people like marmalade, or lemon curd. But, each to his own.

    Reply
  124. Lil, yes, for me (and nana) scones can have fruit like sultanas or currants or dates in them, but that’s about all. Certainly not nuts and chocolate chips. You’re right — I’d call them rock cakes. I think people sometimes don’t realize that the idea is to split the scones and add jam and cream or whatever — some people like marmalade, or lemon curd. But, each to his own.

    Reply
  125. Lil, yes, for me (and nana) scones can have fruit like sultanas or currants or dates in them, but that’s about all. Certainly not nuts and chocolate chips. You’re right — I’d call them rock cakes. I think people sometimes don’t realize that the idea is to split the scones and add jam and cream or whatever — some people like marmalade, or lemon curd. But, each to his own.

    Reply
  126. Kareni, cream horns … yes! I’ve been meaning to make brandy snaps for dessert for some card-playing friends. And mum used to make pikelets, and butter them when they were cold for afternoon tea. Heavens this blog is turning into food porn.

    Reply
  127. Kareni, cream horns … yes! I’ve been meaning to make brandy snaps for dessert for some card-playing friends. And mum used to make pikelets, and butter them when they were cold for afternoon tea. Heavens this blog is turning into food porn.

    Reply
  128. Kareni, cream horns … yes! I’ve been meaning to make brandy snaps for dessert for some card-playing friends. And mum used to make pikelets, and butter them when they were cold for afternoon tea. Heavens this blog is turning into food porn.

    Reply
  129. Kareni, cream horns … yes! I’ve been meaning to make brandy snaps for dessert for some card-playing friends. And mum used to make pikelets, and butter them when they were cold for afternoon tea. Heavens this blog is turning into food porn.

    Reply
  130. Kareni, cream horns … yes! I’ve been meaning to make brandy snaps for dessert for some card-playing friends. And mum used to make pikelets, and butter them when they were cold for afternoon tea. Heavens this blog is turning into food porn.

    Reply
  131. Vicki I’m sure Canadian scones are much like ours. It’s fun to experiment with recipes. Google lemonade scones — there are some variations. I’m not so sure about the mint chocolate chip ones though — Nana made me a purist.

    Reply
  132. Vicki I’m sure Canadian scones are much like ours. It’s fun to experiment with recipes. Google lemonade scones — there are some variations. I’m not so sure about the mint chocolate chip ones though — Nana made me a purist.

    Reply
  133. Vicki I’m sure Canadian scones are much like ours. It’s fun to experiment with recipes. Google lemonade scones — there are some variations. I’m not so sure about the mint chocolate chip ones though — Nana made me a purist.

    Reply
  134. Vicki I’m sure Canadian scones are much like ours. It’s fun to experiment with recipes. Google lemonade scones — there are some variations. I’m not so sure about the mint chocolate chip ones though — Nana made me a purist.

    Reply
  135. Vicki I’m sure Canadian scones are much like ours. It’s fun to experiment with recipes. Google lemonade scones — there are some variations. I’m not so sure about the mint chocolate chip ones though — Nana made me a purist.

    Reply
  136. One makes drop biscuits using Bisquick mixed with water, and no kneading or folding at all. So whatever the difference may be, that’s not it. 🙂 American biscuits are distinctly different in texture and flavor from scones, and that’s my final word on the subject. LOL

    Reply
  137. One makes drop biscuits using Bisquick mixed with water, and no kneading or folding at all. So whatever the difference may be, that’s not it. 🙂 American biscuits are distinctly different in texture and flavor from scones, and that’s my final word on the subject. LOL

    Reply
  138. One makes drop biscuits using Bisquick mixed with water, and no kneading or folding at all. So whatever the difference may be, that’s not it. 🙂 American biscuits are distinctly different in texture and flavor from scones, and that’s my final word on the subject. LOL

    Reply
  139. One makes drop biscuits using Bisquick mixed with water, and no kneading or folding at all. So whatever the difference may be, that’s not it. 🙂 American biscuits are distinctly different in texture and flavor from scones, and that’s my final word on the subject. LOL

    Reply
  140. One makes drop biscuits using Bisquick mixed with water, and no kneading or folding at all. So whatever the difference may be, that’s not it. 🙂 American biscuits are distinctly different in texture and flavor from scones, and that’s my final word on the subject. LOL

    Reply
  141. I am American and I have to say that I thought I knew what tea and scones were until I went to Ireland. NOW I know what REAL tea and scones are and I’ll never go back. I also know what real clotted cream is. My country does a sad imitation of the real thing I’m afraid. Although I have found a decent tea house or two.

    Reply
  142. I am American and I have to say that I thought I knew what tea and scones were until I went to Ireland. NOW I know what REAL tea and scones are and I’ll never go back. I also know what real clotted cream is. My country does a sad imitation of the real thing I’m afraid. Although I have found a decent tea house or two.

    Reply
  143. I am American and I have to say that I thought I knew what tea and scones were until I went to Ireland. NOW I know what REAL tea and scones are and I’ll never go back. I also know what real clotted cream is. My country does a sad imitation of the real thing I’m afraid. Although I have found a decent tea house or two.

    Reply
  144. I am American and I have to say that I thought I knew what tea and scones were until I went to Ireland. NOW I know what REAL tea and scones are and I’ll never go back. I also know what real clotted cream is. My country does a sad imitation of the real thing I’m afraid. Although I have found a decent tea house or two.

    Reply
  145. I am American and I have to say that I thought I knew what tea and scones were until I went to Ireland. NOW I know what REAL tea and scones are and I’ll never go back. I also know what real clotted cream is. My country does a sad imitation of the real thing I’m afraid. Although I have found a decent tea house or two.

    Reply
  146. Yes, Amber, the regional variation thing is important, I think. I can’t recall whether I ever had scones in Ireland or not, but Nana was Irish, so I guess I know what they taste like.

    Reply
  147. Yes, Amber, the regional variation thing is important, I think. I can’t recall whether I ever had scones in Ireland or not, but Nana was Irish, so I guess I know what they taste like.

    Reply
  148. Yes, Amber, the regional variation thing is important, I think. I can’t recall whether I ever had scones in Ireland or not, but Nana was Irish, so I guess I know what they taste like.

    Reply
  149. Yes, Amber, the regional variation thing is important, I think. I can’t recall whether I ever had scones in Ireland or not, but Nana was Irish, so I guess I know what they taste like.

    Reply
  150. Yes, Amber, the regional variation thing is important, I think. I can’t recall whether I ever had scones in Ireland or not, but Nana was Irish, so I guess I know what they taste like.

    Reply
  151. Annabelle’s scones are the best I’ve ever made! So easy, too. You can see her make them at https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=y1xpm2XraU8.
    BTW, re the scone dressing thing, cream first is from Devonshire, jam first is from Cornwall. It makes sense to me that warm scones would soften the cream, so I vote for Devon style.
    In no case should you soften your clotted cream in the microwave. Don’t ask me how I know this. Just … don’t.

    Reply
  152. Annabelle’s scones are the best I’ve ever made! So easy, too. You can see her make them at https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=y1xpm2XraU8.
    BTW, re the scone dressing thing, cream first is from Devonshire, jam first is from Cornwall. It makes sense to me that warm scones would soften the cream, so I vote for Devon style.
    In no case should you soften your clotted cream in the microwave. Don’t ask me how I know this. Just … don’t.

    Reply
  153. Annabelle’s scones are the best I’ve ever made! So easy, too. You can see her make them at https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=y1xpm2XraU8.
    BTW, re the scone dressing thing, cream first is from Devonshire, jam first is from Cornwall. It makes sense to me that warm scones would soften the cream, so I vote for Devon style.
    In no case should you soften your clotted cream in the microwave. Don’t ask me how I know this. Just … don’t.

    Reply
  154. Annabelle’s scones are the best I’ve ever made! So easy, too. You can see her make them at https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=y1xpm2XraU8.
    BTW, re the scone dressing thing, cream first is from Devonshire, jam first is from Cornwall. It makes sense to me that warm scones would soften the cream, so I vote for Devon style.
    In no case should you soften your clotted cream in the microwave. Don’t ask me how I know this. Just … don’t.

    Reply
  155. Annabelle’s scones are the best I’ve ever made! So easy, too. You can see her make them at https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=y1xpm2XraU8.
    BTW, re the scone dressing thing, cream first is from Devonshire, jam first is from Cornwall. It makes sense to me that warm scones would soften the cream, so I vote for Devon style.
    In no case should you soften your clotted cream in the microwave. Don’t ask me how I know this. Just … don’t.

    Reply
  156. I have enjoyed scones…eating not baking. From everything I have read here…it is pretty certain, I have never had a real scone.
    But, as for biscuits and scones – if you can’t sop a scone in good ol’ chicken gravy, it is not the same thing. Shoot fire, good biscuits are great with sausage in the middle. That is no scone.

    Reply
  157. I have enjoyed scones…eating not baking. From everything I have read here…it is pretty certain, I have never had a real scone.
    But, as for biscuits and scones – if you can’t sop a scone in good ol’ chicken gravy, it is not the same thing. Shoot fire, good biscuits are great with sausage in the middle. That is no scone.

    Reply
  158. I have enjoyed scones…eating not baking. From everything I have read here…it is pretty certain, I have never had a real scone.
    But, as for biscuits and scones – if you can’t sop a scone in good ol’ chicken gravy, it is not the same thing. Shoot fire, good biscuits are great with sausage in the middle. That is no scone.

    Reply
  159. I have enjoyed scones…eating not baking. From everything I have read here…it is pretty certain, I have never had a real scone.
    But, as for biscuits and scones – if you can’t sop a scone in good ol’ chicken gravy, it is not the same thing. Shoot fire, good biscuits are great with sausage in the middle. That is no scone.

    Reply
  160. I have enjoyed scones…eating not baking. From everything I have read here…it is pretty certain, I have never had a real scone.
    But, as for biscuits and scones – if you can’t sop a scone in good ol’ chicken gravy, it is not the same thing. Shoot fire, good biscuits are great with sausage in the middle. That is no scone.

    Reply
  161. Thanks, Annette. I suspect you could sop a scone in chicken gravy, but we don’t. They’re not usually made as a breakfast thing. I’ve eaten biscuits with chicken gravy — when I was in New York last my agent made me have a proper American breakfast with grits, biscuits and gravy etc and the biscuits seemed heavier than scones — but then they would with chicken gravy all over them. I don’t think the biscuits or scones debate matters — they’re both yummy.

    Reply
  162. Thanks, Annette. I suspect you could sop a scone in chicken gravy, but we don’t. They’re not usually made as a breakfast thing. I’ve eaten biscuits with chicken gravy — when I was in New York last my agent made me have a proper American breakfast with grits, biscuits and gravy etc and the biscuits seemed heavier than scones — but then they would with chicken gravy all over them. I don’t think the biscuits or scones debate matters — they’re both yummy.

    Reply
  163. Thanks, Annette. I suspect you could sop a scone in chicken gravy, but we don’t. They’re not usually made as a breakfast thing. I’ve eaten biscuits with chicken gravy — when I was in New York last my agent made me have a proper American breakfast with grits, biscuits and gravy etc and the biscuits seemed heavier than scones — but then they would with chicken gravy all over them. I don’t think the biscuits or scones debate matters — they’re both yummy.

    Reply
  164. Thanks, Annette. I suspect you could sop a scone in chicken gravy, but we don’t. They’re not usually made as a breakfast thing. I’ve eaten biscuits with chicken gravy — when I was in New York last my agent made me have a proper American breakfast with grits, biscuits and gravy etc and the biscuits seemed heavier than scones — but then they would with chicken gravy all over them. I don’t think the biscuits or scones debate matters — they’re both yummy.

    Reply
  165. Thanks, Annette. I suspect you could sop a scone in chicken gravy, but we don’t. They’re not usually made as a breakfast thing. I’ve eaten biscuits with chicken gravy — when I was in New York last my agent made me have a proper American breakfast with grits, biscuits and gravy etc and the biscuits seemed heavier than scones — but then they would with chicken gravy all over them. I don’t think the biscuits or scones debate matters — they’re both yummy.

    Reply
  166. I would love to hear from anyone who has made gluten free scones. I have celiac disease which is an auto-immune disorder and it is hazardous to my health if I eat gluten(wheat, barley and rye). Unfortunately our over processed food industry puts it in everything (soup. salad dressings, sauces,candy, gravy as well as baked goods and bread.

    Reply
  167. I would love to hear from anyone who has made gluten free scones. I have celiac disease which is an auto-immune disorder and it is hazardous to my health if I eat gluten(wheat, barley and rye). Unfortunately our over processed food industry puts it in everything (soup. salad dressings, sauces,candy, gravy as well as baked goods and bread.

    Reply
  168. I would love to hear from anyone who has made gluten free scones. I have celiac disease which is an auto-immune disorder and it is hazardous to my health if I eat gluten(wheat, barley and rye). Unfortunately our over processed food industry puts it in everything (soup. salad dressings, sauces,candy, gravy as well as baked goods and bread.

    Reply
  169. I would love to hear from anyone who has made gluten free scones. I have celiac disease which is an auto-immune disorder and it is hazardous to my health if I eat gluten(wheat, barley and rye). Unfortunately our over processed food industry puts it in everything (soup. salad dressings, sauces,candy, gravy as well as baked goods and bread.

    Reply
  170. I would love to hear from anyone who has made gluten free scones. I have celiac disease which is an auto-immune disorder and it is hazardous to my health if I eat gluten(wheat, barley and rye). Unfortunately our over processed food industry puts it in everything (soup. salad dressings, sauces,candy, gravy as well as baked goods and bread.

    Reply

Leave a Comment