HYSTERICAL HISTORICAL TAXES

book cover with Regency couple in front of house
book #5

Pat Rice checking in:

Since the wenches changed up their schedule, I’m supposed to come up with twice as many blogs as before. The problem being. . . I’ve just about finished the last book in my Regency Village Mystery series and I’m toying with an idea set in contemporary California, and I have no historical research to offer. I’m digging into Hollywood mysteries, but I’m not yet ready to commit. So today, I’m pulling on a blog from 2007, because history doesn’t change–and since I’d doing taxes as well, it only seems fitting.

As a former CPA, I’m capable of finding taxes humorous. I read an article that argues we comical policeman collecting cashshould give up outlawing things that are bad for us and tax them instead. That makes total sense to me.  We already tax cigarettes and alcohol and gas.  Why not charge taxes on trans fat if society has to pay for your ills?  If marijuana is our biggest cash crop, as the author claims, just think of all the mental hospitals we could build by taxing it!

But when he got down to taxing McMansions and Maseratis, he hit my history nerd nerve.  Taxing conspicuous consumption has been done.  The original taxes had absolutely nothing to do with taxing things that are bad for us and everything to do with taxing the rich, so naturally, I had to dig out my tax research. I am not opposed to taxing the wealthy, but as we all know, human nature is not predictable. bricked up windows on tall buildingConsequences happen.

The first attack on McMansions, seventeenth century style, came in 1697, when England passed a law assessing a tax on buildings according to the number of windows and openings they had.  Any building with more than six windows got hit with a tax bill. Just think of those castles and all their openings!  In its first year, the tax raised 1,200,000 pounds!  Heck, I wonder if an arrow slit counted? Can you just imagine the screams if we hit people with a tax of $1000 a window for houses with what, more than a dozen windows maybe? What could possibly happen?

Well, in the case of the English, they just quit putting windows in buildings.  Or bricked up the old ones. Did the government quit taxing them? Of course not. Apparently they enjoyed living in darkness, because they increased the tax six times between 1747 and 1808 and never entirely got rid of it until 1851.  And the money was so lovely that France has a similar tax to this day. Which teaches one to be very wary of suggesting taxes to governments!portrait of Peter the Great

Got a war you want to finance? Peter the Great came up with a charming method of taxing  souls to pay for his military might. Apparently, only men have souls, and then, only if they aren’t part of the nobility and the clergy (what a broad-minded thinker was old Peter—the rich don’t have souls and weren’t taxed!), and you couldn’t prove you were soul-less (or even spineless) by leaving town, because then they taxed the town for your useless soul.  Better yet, if you were one of those old-fashioned types who didn’t accept Pete’s modern church beliefs, you got taxed double!  Not certain if Old Pete meant nature-worshippers had twice the soul, but I’m sure those freethinkers were twice as much trouble as orthodox believers.

And Peter was such an imaginative man, he even taxed beards. Taxing conspicuous hair growth instead of consumption must have made it easy for the tax collectors! Guess he figured all those peasants were saving money by not going to a barber and ought to pay to support the haircut industry, although I’m pretty certain he put the tax to work by paying barbers to be soldiers.

cartoon of woman having tall wig powderedOh, and back to taxes on the rich—in 1795, William Pitt the Younger, not a dull or stupid man by any means, decided to tax wig and hair powder to pay for all those soldiers he had to keep buying. Maybe he thought all those good-looking young redcoats in their fancy wigs would be better off without them, because that’s more or less what happened. Rather than pay the tax, men abandoned wigs and powder and whacked off their queues, thus ushering in the Regency-era style of shorn locks and no powder. Of course, he also put a lot of wigmakers out of business… Because, y’know, taxes have consequences.

And then there’s always Lady Godiva, who talked her husband out of charging outrageous taxes by pulling off her equally outrageous stunt.  I can’t see that helping a lot these days!

All right, fire up your imaginations. What taxes would you charge to pay for our sins? Do you know of any modern taxes on sins?  

 

 

16 thoughts on “HYSTERICAL HISTORICAL TAXES”

  1. Fun in a chilling way, Pat! But going naked to avoid taxation is definitely not going to work. Not when so many actresses and influencer will strip as far as they can get away with in order to get noticed!

    Reply
  2. I am not sure there are many things considered sins left to tax! People thses days seemcto vye with each to see hkw si cul they can be! But I guess the most money for taxes might be collected by placing a tax on lying , rumors a d spreading false information!
    Thjnk kf the billions kf dollars kne could collect with that one! (And mayb
    Be get people to srop doing it so fequently?).

    Reply
      • It depends. Some lies and falsehoods are amazingly transparent But then, people have always believed what they want to believe even if it is right before their eyes. The sky is blue, but some people will believe it js yellow because s9me8ne says so and they are willing to believe it, all evidence to the contrary.

        Reply
  3. I hate taxes & I hate getting ready to prepare all the stuff for our accountant. Plus I haven’t figured out how to make the scanner work on my newish computer. I switched from windows to a Mac so things work a little differently.

    Reply
  4. Thank you for a fascinating post, Pat. I knew that England taxed windows at one time but had no idea that France did/does. I’d not known of taxing souls; we can doubtless agree that while some who are wealthy are soulless so are some who are poor. Hmm, just please don’t tax chocolate! Or books!!

    Reply
  5. I had heard about Peter the Great taxing souls, because the plot of Gogol’s classic Russian novel “Dead Souls” revolves around it. Russian landowners at the time had to pay the soul tax for all the serfs that lived on their estates, and since census records were updated infrequently, they often ended up paying for serfs who were no longer alive. In the book, which is a satirical black comedy, a conman character offers to “buy” the dead souls and relieve those rich landowners of their tax burden. It’s all part of a get-rich-quick scheme, and the story gets crazier from there.

    Reply
    • Ooo, I’m not familiar with that one! Thank you. So many books that ought to be taught in schools and never are… Although here, they are now teaching 1984, which makes me very happy.

      Reply
  6. In the UK we found that a threat of taxing the rich leads to the richest people emigrating, thus making us all poorer …. unintended consequences again! The economists tell us that the only way for the country as a whole to get richer is to stimulate growth ….. (so maybe eating more will help *LOL*) ….. we need to reduce taxes to achieve this!!

    The biggest sin I can think of is the way humanity has polluted the planet leading to accelerated climate change. Geologists also tell us that we are approaching a new ice age so that we need to be researching ways to survive as a species. I would put a survival tax on everything to support research into this (including nuclear fusion).

    Reply
    • I like that, a survival tax! Here in California, we are trying to pass a tax on the rich for one year only, which would make it a pain to just pick up and move. But as a CPA, I can foresee the horror of trying to figure out how and what to tax since we’re not talking W-2 wage forms. The whole country would have to do this and set up the paperwork. Given that our tax on the rich in the 1950s was 90%, they shouldn’t complain.

      But I’d love to see an oil tax to provide for researching!

      Reply
      • Interesting idea to tax the rich for one year. Wish our PM would read your blog!
        I had in mind increasing income tax which would be easy to implement but a tax on oil and gas could also work. As a CPA you might have been one of the rich so the attraction of writing romance must have been very powerful to lead to a switch …. though I guess some successful authors qualify as rich, and anyway job satisfaction supercedes financial reward for most of us!

        Reply
        • I was a female CPA in a very small town–very definitely not rich. My author income exceeded my accounting for several years before I gave up the day job.
          Increasing income tax here is so vastly unpopular that it would never pass. Tell your PM to listen to our gov, Gavin Newsom. He’s the one who came up with the one year idea.

          Reply

Leave a Comment

Protected by CleanTalk Anti-Spam