History Repeats

book cover Madman's Dangerous DelusionI’m still piddling around with the beginning of Book #6 in The Gravesyde Village Mystery series. I have two couples who resist romantic endings and I’m trying to hit them over their heads and wake them up to reality. Apparently, my Muse thought a few riots might help. Gee, I wonder where she got that idea? Probably because today’s newspapers aren’t that different from the news in 1816.

My characters exist in 1816 but they naturally have knowledge of the years before that, when the Luddites made a riotous  path across England. The unhappy Luddites named themselves after Ned Ludd, a possibly apocryphal apprentice who smashed stockingframes in 1779 after being criticized for his method of using them. The name didn’t show up until around 1811, when the unhappy skilled weavers began sacking automated looms that replaced their handmade goods. The name Luddite became a smashed computername for anyone who complains about technology changing the world around them. In a way, I suppose, we’re all Luddites. I’d like to smash a few computers and a TV or two, anyway. And don’t get me started on AI! Personally, I think media and technology are killing us more surely than automation starved those poor weavers. But we can’t turn back time, as the Luddites discovered.

engraving of LudditeFrom 1811 to 1816 they gathered and rioted and wrote letters of protest and destroyed looms across the countryside. Instead of listening to their fairly justified complaints—they’d been put out of the only jobs they knew, their families were starving, and the companies had no interest in workers who knew weaving better than the cheap labor being hired (shades of AI!)—the government chose to intimidate them by arresting sixty men and holding a mass trial at York in 1813. Some of those charged may have actually been engaged in destroying machines, but many had no connection whatsoever. The government simply wanted to make a very large example and put an end to the protesting. Eventually thirty were acquitted due to lack of evidence, but some were executed and transported. (Really, doesn’t this all sound vaguely familiar? That’s history for you!)

The protests did not end. So the mill and factory owners simply took to shooting the protestors. Eventually, it took 12,000 government troops, to suppress those poor Luddite destroying mill cartoonweavers, a larger army than the Duke of Wellington led into Portugal in 1808 during the Peninsular War. (I mean, c’mon, wouldn’t it have been simpler and cheaper to listen and fix the problem?)

Unimpressed, the citizens of England continued to riot and protest after the Luddites gave up. With the end of the continental war, soldiers were sent home without pensions. Left unemployed, many lived homeless on the streets. The war had depleted the economy, the banks, and the fields. Topping that off, the Year Without a Summer (brought on by a series of volcanic eruptions around the world, over a short period of time) occurred in 1816, ruining pamphlet on Corn Lawscrops. And then, the great nobles with their immense estates, suffering from empty fields and unpaid rents, passed the Corn Laws, guaranteeing that a bushel of any kind of grain had a base price that made them wealthy but only the rich could afford to buy.

To see the song depicted in the image, click on this pdf file

Unable to afford basic grain, people went without bread. These were the kind of conditions that brought about the French Revolution. But the Brits, too polite to pull down the Tower of London (although one group thought about it), held rallies, wrote speeches and letters, and delivered petitions to the prince regent requesting electoral reform and relief from hardship.

Ignored on all fronts, a crowd in Islington broke into a gunsmith’s and fired on the Royal Exchange. Other incidents followed, to the point that sedition laws were called upon, ending 1816 in spectacular riots and outcries.old fashioned loom

So, ha, I have riots and sedition to prod my complacent characters into action. Now if only I had a murder for them to solve. . .

But my wandering point is that we can look to history to see the ultimate results of current events. I’m only picking on Regency England because that’s what I’m currently writing about. But any time the people in power ignore the poor and suffering, there will be an unhappy populace. As history tells us, the results depend on how long the government ignores the cries of the trod upon. Surely, I can turn that into a murder or two. . .

PS: Anne just pointed out this blog from Philippa Gregory to me that shows history repeating itself in the form of Henry VIII. Frightening, isn’t it?

 

 

 

13 thoughts on “History Repeats”

  1. Thank you for the post, Pat. It’s chilling to see the comparison to our time. Technology will continue to expand. More riots might erupt, but for more reasons than the strength of AI. When the public’s basic needs are no longer met, they won’t care about who gets hurt. You’ll have plenty of chances for all sorts of murder and mayhem in the story.

    Reply
  2. One of the things I love about your series, Pat, is the sense of community. Those in charge try to find ways to help those in need even if it means having to settle for less for yourself- And it ends up enriching everyone else.

    Reply
  3. Pat, I wish more people would read this. I’ve had several arguments with a friend trying to convince him that history is an important subject, but he just insists that the past is irrelevant because everything is different now. Grrrr!

    Reply
    • different, but the same. We’re not smashing looms, admittedly, but the build-up against AI… could be interesting. And we’re already seeing what happens when there is rapid technological change… we go backward as fast as we can.

      Reply
    • Shows how much history he knows, doesn’t it? The ones who say that are too often those who know very little about history. It’s like criticizing a book when you have only read tge blurb! It’s a shame.

      Reply

Leave a Comment

Protected by CleanTalk Anti-Spam