By Mary Jo
This month the Wenches are talking about film adaptations of movies. What we loved, what we hated, and what we’d like to see made. What adaptations have you loved or hated?

Anne here. In general, I prefer the book to the movie. There’s so much more in the book; characters’ thoughts, impressions, backstory, and things like subplots and minor characters that the movie makers often have to cut. But it’s a bit like comparing apples with oranges — they do different things. One adaptation I really enjoyed was the BBC version of Pride and Prejudice, the one with Jennifer Ehle and Colin Firth, but that was serialized, so it was able to include a lot of things that a movie of the same book would have to miss out on. That said, I did enjoy the 2005 movie with Keira Knightley and Matthew Macfadyen, even though there were some things that really annoyed me — like that pig wandering through the house! And the old movie of To Kill A Mockingbird, with Gregory Peck was brilliant and though it had to leave some of the book out, it conveyed its essence superbly.
But in general, I don’t rush to watch adaptations. I only watched a little bit of Bridgerton, for example, and though I’ve read Wuthering Heights a number of times, I’m not lining up to go and watch the new film adaptation. I never liked the book and from everything I’ve heard about the film, it won’t convert me. I understand why movie people want to make over old books and stories to appeal to a new audience, but I don’t particularly enjoy their flights of fancy.
But if I haven’t read the original book, often watching a movie will entice me to read it. I read One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest after seeing and enjoying the movie, for instance. The same with M.A.S.H. after seeing the movie and the TV show. They were different, but I felt the essence was ‘right’ and the book respected. And there are movies that are much better than the book: The Princess Bride, for example. I saw the movie first, and hoped to like the book more, but I didn’t.
Christina here. I’m the same as Anne and usually much prefer the book to the movie. However, also like her, I really enjoyed the BBC TV adaptation of Pride & Prejudice, as well as the film version of Sense & Sensibility starring Emma Thompson. And I loved the Jane Eyre TV series starring Toby Stephens. I quite enjoyed the Lord of the Rings trilogy. I saw the films first and they made me want to read the books. I had tried in the past and never got into them but once I’d seen the movies it all made more sense somehow.
Most of the time I find movie adaptations disappointing because they leave out some of what I consider important stuff. If it’s a film there isn’t enough time to fit everything in and sometimes they simply don’t catch the essence of the book. One movie that was better than the book though was Inkheart (based on the book by Cornelia Funke). The reason I liked it so much was because the film gives us a happy ending whereas the book didn’t (sorry if that’s a spoiler!). I would really, really love to see some TV adaptations of Georgette Heyer’s stories. I think her dry humour could come across brilliantly if it was done properly. Any producers out there listening?
Nicola here. I’m another one who usually prefers books to films. Generally, you get so much more depth in a book compared to a two-hour summary of a story in a movie. TV adaptations are often better because there are more episodes, which allows for a greater exploration of the themes and characters. I was massively disappointed in the 1998 film of Frenchman’s Creek, which is one of my all-time favourite books. I thought Anthony Delon as the pirate hero was always smirking rather irritatingly and all the subtlety and magic of the original story was lost for me. I’ve had a similar reaction to a number of Jane Austen adaptations although not all of them.
However, one film I loved was The Personal History of David Copperfield, based on the book by Charles Dickens. I don’t enjoy reading Dickens. I’ve really tried to get into his books but they just aren’t for me. So, I approached this movie with a certain wariness and was very pleasantly surprised. It’s funny, clever and the characters are really engaging. I’ve no idea if it’s true to the original book but that doesn’t matter. I thought it was charming. So perhaps the answer (for me at least) is not to watch adaptations of books I have loved but to try something new!
An adaptation I’d really like to see? Hmm, a time slip story like The Rose Garden by Susanna Kearsley would be absolutely brilliant!

Susan King here: Often it seems movie adaptations are not quite as good as the original book, but there are lots of wonderful notable exceptions. One of the best screen adaptations of a book that I’ve read (and read before the movie was out) is The Martian, starring Matt Damon and based on the novel by Andy Weir. The book, an amazing blockbuster, is a powerful story packed with accurate scientific information and plausible life-or-death situations. When a group of astronauts must suddenly abandon their habitat on Mars in a storm, they believe one of their team died in a freak accident, and they reluctantly leave the planet. But Mark Watney is very much alive and must survive alone on the planet, using science, creative solutions, and incredible resilience until a highly dangerous rescue can be arranged.
The book was excellent, but can be bit of an uphill read with all the scientific information to absorb. The movie presents the same story in an exciting, fast-paced way that emphasizes character over science, makes the science very accessible, and laces humor throughout, even in the darkest moments. Matt Damon’s Mark Watney is a remarkable performance, close to the book yet far more endearing. It’s a fantastic movie, a favorite in our household, and so watchable that we’ve seen it more than once and will probably watch it again.
Andrea here: I’m usually leery of film adaptations of books. All too often, so much gets lost in translation. I do like both Pride & Prejudice films mentioned by the other Wenches, but mostly because they are nice period entertainments, though I don’t think they really capture Austen’s nuances.
That said, I do have few films that I think do a wonderful job of both capturing the spirit of the book and bringing an extra bit magic through the medium of film. First on the list is The Princess Bride, which is one of my all-time favorites. All the actors are so perfectly cast and capture the zany tongue-in-cheek mood of the book. In fact, when the film deviates from the book, it’s for the better! I’ve seen it umpteen times and still laugh at every joke or sight gag.
I also think the Harry Potter films, and the Lord of the Rings trilogy are fabulous at bring to life the world and characters of Hogwarts and Middle Earth.
Pat here. I seldom watch movies and barely remember those that I have, sorry. Yes, I’ve seen the various versions of P&P and Sense and Sensibility and they were very pretty and well done for what they were—a nice bit of scenery and acting. They captured some of the essence of the books, which given the limited time span of a movie, is well done. And therein lies the rub—books allow for so much more!
I’m in a book club that reads books made into movies. We tend literary, mostly, so the differences between the two media is extremely noticeable. Literary books are generally heavy on description and atmosphere and meaningful pauses where the reader can sit and ponder the portents and philosophies and themes. Movies are far more fun in this case. <G> They’re entertainment: beautiful people, beautiful scenery, a fast-paced story to please a wide audience. Film necessarily leaves out bits that I enjoyed or thought were extremely important to the book—but weren’t necessary for entertainment. Books like The Boys in the Boat or The Tender Bar (and yes, we have a George Clooney fan in the group) are filled with fascinating details that the movies turned into action sequences. And heck, let’s admit it, it’s far more fun to watch Clooney than to plod through old history!
Mary Jo here: I join the other Wenches I admiring some of the Jane Austen adaptations, and I think the Lord of the Rings trilogy was magnificent. (Since I’d read the books years early, I wasn’t hung up about what was left out.)
Sometimes movies I’m enjoyed have encouraged me to read the book. It doesn’t usually work the other way. If I read the book first, the movie often will seem lacking because there is so much that had to be left out.
I enjoy most of the same stories-to-movies that the other Wenches have mentioned, but I wanted to elaborate on The Princess Bride. The movie has become a much loved classic, popular with people of all ages. I never read Goldman’s book which was the inspiration for the movie, but if you enjoy the movie, I recommend reading As You Wish: Inconceivable Tales from the Making of The Princess Bride.
Written by Cary Elwes, who plays Westley, the romantic lead in The Princess Bride, the book is great fun, describing the actors and the ups and downs of the shooting. It also gives insights into how movies are made. The casting was brilliant–it’s hard to imagine any other actors in the roles. Elwes and Mandy Patinkin spent endless hours practicing their swordsmanship for the key scene between them. The dramatic Cliffs of Moher became the fearsome Cliffs of Insanity, Reading the book is as much fun as watching the movie.
What about you? Do you love or hate movie adaptations of books? If so, which ones?










I’ll add one books to screen adaption I think was well done, and that is A Discovery of Witches. Three books were turned into three seasons. I suspect one reason it worked so well is that the author was involved in the production. Best of all for me was that the second book, set mostly in the sixteenth century, was much more accurate than most historical films. Okay, yes, the stories involve witches, vampires, and demons, but they were placed in as real a setting as I’ve ever seen in a TV production. It probably helped that the author has also written nonfiction set in that era.
LOL, Kathy! As long as the witches and vampires and demons were real, it makes a much more convincing movies.
I love those books, Kathy. I thought the casting was great for the series too.
I can’t say that I either love or hate them. In general I would prefer the book any day because there is just so much more that the screen cannot convey. Sometimes background narration helps to see the inner thoughts of the characters. A production of Emma from the 90s uses the narration effectively. And it helped with To Kill A Mockingbird.
I too love the BBC production of P&P – Colin Firth (sigh). And there are several of the many productions of Jane Eyre that I enjoyed. Bridgertons didn’t work for me either. And I too am not a fan of Wurthering Heights – book or movies.
Loved this post.
Mary T: Altogether now: Colin Firth SIGH!!!
Christina, I’m with you on wishing somebody would adapt Georgette Heyer. The humour & snappy dialogue would be perfect for film or TV.
One film which I think was a very skilful adaptation of the book was LA Confidential. The book is a big, messy sprawling, hyper novel. The film script slashed & burned, somehow getting it down to a manageable coherent length.
Ginger Cat, it’s true that sometimes the adaptation is going to be better and and more rewarding.
I’m not a fan of Georgette Heyer (yes, yes, I know that’s appalling.) So consider that as I write this: I think those books are too old fashioned to translate well to the screen. OTOH, the Downton Abbey tv show and movies, and the Bridgerton series, show there’s an audience for costume drama. So maybe those could succeed as adaptations with a good script.
I’ll add that I really enjoyed Downton Abbey and have a weakness for costume drama myself! I haven’t watched Bridgerton or read the books.
I think that us interesting that you think Heyer too old fashioned to be translated to screen and yet Jane Austen and other 19th c writers are not?
One of my favorite rewatches is the BBC production of Persuasion with Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds. It’s my favorite Jane Austen and I think the film captured the bittersweet tone as well as the humor of the book.
I also enjoy the BBC production series of Elizabeth Gaskell’s North and South, with Daniela Denby-Ashe and Richard Armitage. It’s more overtly romantic than the book, but wonderfully evocative of the world created in the book. (I’ve never seen Denby-Ashe in anything else, but she’s just luminous in this.)
Constance, I’m totally with you on that version of PERSUASION. I’m fond of the book, and that film version is lovely. “You want to marry ANNE?!!!” And then that big beautiful smile from Ciaran Hinds.)
Christina – there is a movie on YouTube – The Reluctant Widow by Georgette Heyer. It’s not great quality and I will warn that if anyone tries to watch it, it starts out similar to the book and very quickly it changes almost everything. 🙂 I watched it because I was curious and I agree that Heyer on screen would be so much fun if someone actually took the time to do it well.
And I have to 2nd Mary Jo’s recommendation to read As You Wish. It was such a good book.
Misti–I’ve read that Heyer hated the adaptation of The Reluctant Widow that she refused permission to make movies of any of her other books.
I can understand why she refused permission for any more adaptations of her books—The Reluctant Widow is absolutely awful.
A part of me would love to see Georgette Heyer adapted, but seeing as someone managed to ruin Persuasion and Rebecca – two of the greatest novels in the English language, in my opinion – I’m hesitant that the books will fall in the wrong hands and the adaptation will be atrocious.
I did enjoy the I Capture the Castle, the Cranford, Jane Eyre with Toby Stephens and Ruth Wilson and the North and South adaptation (surely we are due another one – although how do you improve on perfection?) and the 1995 Pride and Prejudice is surely the gold standard by which all adaptations should be measured. I did enjoy the Keira Knightley version although it’s not strictly my favourite.
I think there is an adaptation of an Agatha Christie that changed the identity of the murderer, so if screenwriters are taken such liberties, I think I’ll stick to the books!
Yes, normally the book is better but sometimes the adaptations work just because the screenwriters did such a good job finding the essence. Prince of Tides is one of my favorites even though there are many things left out. I will soon be streaming Hamnet & can’t wait to see how it compares to the wonderful book. The author was involved so I have high hopes. As for what I would like to see done – well, I always thought Jo Beverley’s books would be fun to watch.
I am not generally a movie watcher, but my husband can usually lure me into joining him by offering to watch The Martian. I agree that it’s a great movie, Susan…though I still like the book better! (My husband and I both have degrees in Chemistry, so the science was a plus.)
I agree that the Princess Bride movie was more enjoyable than the book.
A children’s movie that I think improved on the book was Babe which was based on The Sheep-Pig (British title) or Babe, the Gallant Pig (American title) by Dick King-Smith. The book contained a lot of regional dialect which I found challenging to read.
Kareni–fun for chemists! Even with much chemistry knowledge, it’s a very good movie. The movie Babe was great fun, but I’m not impressed by the titles of the book. (The Sheep-Pig???)
My favorite adaptation of Pride and Prejudice is the one with David Rintoul and Elizabeth Garvie. It’s the novel at its best and most complete without excessive emotion.
I like the version with Jennifer Ehles and Colin Firth because of the lake scene and more emotional content.
I saw the documentary on Public Television, The Boys of ’36, and I read The Boys in the Boat: Nine Americans and Their Epic Quest for Gold at the 1936 Olympics, by Daniel James Brown, who is a brilliant writer. Both are excellent.
Patricia – I totally agree with you on that version of P&P!
Let me start by saying, I love a good movie. If I really love a book, I am not sure I want to see it made into a movie because there are usually too many changes made so that the only thing left are the names of the characters and the title. The producers and script writer want to make their mark on the movie and want to alleal to the younger generation, so they try to appeal to the younger folks by adding or changing things for the movie that either weren’t in the book or tweak it.
While I would love to see Georgette Heyer’s novels made into either a tv series or a movie, i am afraid to see it done because the producers and scrupt writer will change it so “younger audiences will understand it better”. They will modernize the language, add sex scenes, and basically ruin the story. So unless they can keep Heyer as Heyer, I do not want them messing with her books.
Having said that, there are many well done movies from books that I adore and will mention some here.
My favorite Austen movies are the 1980 BBC versiin with Elizabeth Garvie and David Rintoul, 1995 version of Persuasion and the Sense and Sensibility frrom the 1990’s. The costumes, the faithfulness to Austen’s story, the dialog and the the costumes were all very well done.
I alwo liked the Lord of The Rings trilogy with Ian Mckellan. Very well done.
Another well done book to movie was The Ghost and Mrs Muir, the choice of actors and the almost literal transfer from the book to the movie was amazing.
The same can be said for the Prisoner of Zenda with a stellar cast and very little change in the movie from the book. The movie Somewhere in Time was also well done from Matheson,s book “Bid Time Return”. The movie captured the atmosphere and the characters beautifully. When book is transfered to the screen, especially a popular one, the producer needs to be careful not to ruin what made the book so popular to begin with. It the story and characters are treated properly, the movie can add a wonderful dimension to the book, if not, it can be a real disappointment.
Colin Firth…be still my heart! His Darcy certainly eclipses the Laurence Olivier (1940) version. I also like two versions of Jane Eyre-Orson Welles, and much later, Timothy Dalton. I first read Jane Eyre as a romance, but nuch later, I realized the book was a glimpse into the reality of the time in which Charlotte Bronte lived. And, of course, even seven hours of film weren’t enough to capture the gargantuan scale of Tolstoy’s War and Peace. I saw the movie (in two segments) when I was in graduate school. I was desperate to read the book, so I bought a slightly ratty copy for $2.00. Of course, I had a perfectly good copy at home-but home was 900 miles away and I simply couldn’t wait to learn more about Pierre Bezuchov. The film won the Academy Award for best foreign film.
I know I’m in the minority, but I’m not a fan of The Princess Bride movie, so I’ve never tried to read the book. I don’t hate it, I just feel ‘meh’ about it.
I do love The Last of the Mohicans with Daniel Day Lewis, it is beautifully filmed and so romantic, a definite improvement over the book.
There are two different Dorothy Sayers TV adaptations. The 1970’s BBC series with Ian Carmichael I have trouble with, because he just doesn’t look like Lord Peter Wimsey, the way he’s described in the books, or my mental image. It’s also missing the books that feature Harriet Vane! The 1980’s BBC series, on the other hand, has the perfect Lord Peter, played my Edward Petherbridge, and Harriet Walter is a great Harriet Vane. They are free to watch on YouTube, if anyone is interested.
The great crime novelist Elmore Leonard has been lucky with the many, many film adaptations of his books, including Out of Sight, Get Shorty and Jackie Brown, and the Western movie, Hombre, with Paul Newman. I’m also fond of the original 1957 adaptation of 3:10 to Yuma and Mr. Majestyk with Charles Bronson. But Leonard’s books are perfect cinema. he’s a master of dialogue. He just captures the way people actually talk.
I too like adaptations of books if they’re done well. For Austen, the 1980 version of P&P and the Amanda Root Persuasion are my favourites. I did also like the tv series of Sense and Sensibility with Hattie Morahan. It was very good only for Colonel Brandon. I didn’t like David Morrisey in the part.
Georgette Heyer!!! If only!! Would absolutely love to see her books adapted but the way Netflix do series I would be afraid. I haven’t seen any of their adaptations that I’ve liked. I never liked Wuthering Heights so won’t be watching that!!
Susanna Kearsley’s books I would love to see as well.
And I adored Inkheart (could also have something to do with Brendan Fraser) 😊
Thoroughly enjoyable post!!
It is easy to understand why the readers of this column are the faithful readers of this column. So many heads (like mine) were surely nodding as they read each of the Wenches’ posts.
Anne- I loved and agreed with each word you wrote.
Susan- I loved The Martian, both iterations. Matt Damon didn’t hurt either!
Andrea- I love everything you write- always.
Mary Joe- I loved everything about The Princess Bride and I bought the book about the movie. Happy for that heads up.
I do agree that so many books to movies are disappointments. They are such different art forms and can be loved for each of their own highs and lows.
My opinion on this is that I generally enjoy the book more than the movie version, for the same reason others give here: there’s generally more context in the book. That said, if the movie generally stays with the spirit of the book (best word I can come up with), then I’m OK with it. I do tend to see the characters in the book as looking like the actors in the movie if I re-read the book after seeing the movie!
And sometimes after I see the TV show or the movie, it will introduce me to the book or books it’s based on. Example: the Dresden Files tv show.
Quite often though, adaptations are just awful. One example is Starship Troopers. It just doesn’t capture the book at all beyond using the characters’ names and some details. The adaptation of another Heinlein novel, The Puppet Masters, was OK, but it just kind of lacked…I don’t know, the spirit of the book. And I could go on, with other examples that aren’t science fiction, but I won’t.
Re science fiction books, maybe it’s just hard to adapt them in a way that works for a mass audience? Maybe because they often deal with topics that aren’t of interest to mass audiences. Idk, I liked the original 1984 Dune movie, but then, I loved the book. But so many people hated that adaptation. The recent remakes seem to have done better.
Like most people here, I generally prefer the book to the movie, but I have a soft spot for the old (1940s) Great Expectations with John Mills and the Alastair Sims Christmas Carol. That may be because I am not a great fan of Dickens, so I don’t mind the stuff that got left out.
I also love the Ronald Colman-Douglas Fairbanks Jr. Prisoner of Zenda, which I thought was better than the book. Frequently, movies can do action better than books can, especially sword fights.
Just as good as books are audiobooks, for those of us experiencing eye issues. Specially with Bluetooth, and following the text from books, with descriptions galore. I can’t always get to the movies. I prefer the audiobooks, as I get everything the book/writer is conveying……and I get to do something else with my hands as well – housework, gardening, arts and crafts. Whatever my hands need to do.