Christina here and today’s Ask A Wench question is “What is your favourite ‘sinful’ food indulgence that you always allow yourself during the holiday season!” Brace yourselves for some truly delicious treats!
Pat: My favorite sinful indulgence? Sugar! So very much sugar … I am a sugarholic. I do my very best to keep goodies out of the house, because, if they’re around, I eat them. But over the holidays, anything goes. It’s impossible to resist all the lovely chocolates and munchies everyone sets out, expecting guests to indulge. It’s impossible to make Christmas dinner without pies and cakes. And one must have cookies, at the very least, on hand for guests. Since we have lemons, we have lemon bars, lemon-blueberry cakes! and lemon brownies and … you get the message. They may have nutritious Vitamin C but do you have any idea how much sugar it takes to turn lemons into cookies?
Anne: My holiday indulgence is sweet food, and especially chocolate. I enjoy baking, but I usually only bake biscuits (ie cookies) when I’m anticipating visitors. But in the lead-up to Christmas I always do a lot of baking, as I like giving people biscuits and sweets like Christmas Crack. Most of my friends have everything they need, so for the annual get-togethers I attend that ask for a small Kris Kringle gift, I bring a tin of home-baked biscuits.
I used to make homemade chocolates, and when I moved a couple of years ago, I found my old chocolate moulds, so I might make those for a change. My other sinful indulgence at Christmas is pavlova. Our Christmas comes in summer, so even though I like plum pudding and always buy a charity one, I often make a pavlova — again, to take to a lunch or dinner. But hey — it’s fruit, right?
Andrea: I’ve never said “no” when offered chocolate during the holiday season! (But in the spirit of full disclosure, I never say “no” to chocolate at any time of the year!). Chocolate is always so alluring in December — all those lovely little bonbons wrapped in colorful foil, or gooey baked treats, or big chunks of sin-dark chocolate studded with nuts … They are are SO hard to resist.

However my favorite holiday indulgence is a Swiss pastry called Appenzeller Biber. A traditional specialty of the Appenzell region, it is a “To-Die for “combination of two layers of gingerbread pastry with a thick layer of marzipan sandwiched inside. The Swiss version is always decorated by pressing a wooden mold into the top layer of the gingerbread that usually features a bear or the canton’s crest. Years ago, my mother and I did some research and found a recipe for it, and I bake a homemade version of it every Christmas. (No bear but extra marzipan!). It’s very rich — and very delicious! (One can also make it into little bite-size cookies, which is what my older brother does). Hey, calories don’t count in December, right?
Nicola: For me the holiday season is all about cheese! I eat cheese the rest of the year, of course, but I go into cheese over-drive at this time of the year. Top of my list of favourites is smoked salmon roulade with cream cheese. Naturally I will also have cheese and crackers. Then there are the herb and cheese fritters that we only make at holiday time because they are so fiddly to do but so worth it for a special occasion. You have to grate six different types of cheese to mix in with herbs, eggs, milk, flour and a pinch of cayenne pepper. There’s also a homemade tomato and balsamic jam to go with it. It requires a production line of grating, mixing, shaping and griddling but the fritters are melt-in-the-mouth delicious. We try not to eat them too quickly after all that hard work. Finally, there is the piece de resistance which is cheese served with Christmas cake. Cheddar goes so well with fruit cake and sweet icing. Having cheese with cake is a Yorkshire tradition from my childhood. Some people are horrified by the combination but it tastes fantastic, to me at least. After all that indulgence I will probably fall asleep and have cheese-induced dreams …

Mary Jo: The holiday season has a distracting array of goodies, but I’m particularly fond of the beautiful French cake known as a “bûche de Noël,” or a Yule Log cake in English. Developed in France in the 19th century, it was originally found mostly in French speaking countries, but in recent years has become more popular in the US.
It’s basically a roll cake with a sponge base baked in a large flat pan. After baking it’s spread with icing, then carefully rolled up. The outside is lushly iced again with a fork or spoon being used to create a rough, bark-like texture. Chocolate icing is popular because it makes the cake look more log-like. Sometimes one end of the cake is cut off and reapplied at an angle as another way of making it look more like a log.
Often the cake itself is vanilla, but there are any number of variations. Decorations are added, including things like meringue mushrooms, berries, or inedible items like season’s greetings, little sleighs, Santa Clauses, tiny Christmas trees or whatever else the baker chooses.
My first acquaintance with a bûche de Noël was at a nearby French bakery which produces marvelous treats and is fortunately enough off my usual path that I don’t get there often. <G> Made with the best ingredients, there were beautifully decorated chocolate and vanilla logs large enough to serve at a party. (Which I did.)
Since then I’ve seen Yule log cakes more often in regular grocery stores. The basic chocolate roll cake is delicious, and the appearance and decorations are a delightful holiday treat. Time I ordered one for this Christmas!

Susan: What treat do I love for the holidays? Gingerbread! It’s a delicious bit of indulgence that comes in so many varieties – gingerbread cake, gingerbread cookies, gingerbread men, ginger snaps, gingerbread houses … I love spicy gingerbread and I’d eat it any time of year, but of all the desserts and treats, that one means Christmas to me. When my boys were little, we made trays of gingerbread men and constructed gingerbread houses decorated with candies and frosting – those houses were adorable, though they rarely looked perfect, and the kids had a great time decorating and then plucking away at them until they were demolished.

These days I’ll make gingerbread cake though I’ve discovered a local bakery that makes a scrumptious gingerbread bundt cake with drizzles of cream cheese frosting. The last few years, I’ve ordered it for our holiday gathering, and any leftover slices go in the freezer to be gobbled now and then until gone. Gingerbread has a long history too, ancient, medieval, Renaissance, Tudor, 19th century – name an era and you’d find some form of ginger cakes and biscuits, sometimes as desserts, sometimes to soothe the stomach, as ginger is helpful for tummy aches. And let us not forget the Gingerbread Man in fairy tales, and also spicy, feisty, funny, brave Gingy in Shrek, who makes sure his friends get safely away even if it puts him in peril. Run, run, as fast as you can …
Christina: I’m with everyone else – chocolate is a must at Christmas! My favourite chocolatey treats are home made and they are incredibly simple – you just melt some chocolate (either milk, dark or both) and add puffed rice. Make sure the rice is completely coated then scoop up bite-sized portions onto a tray and place in the fridge until the chocolate has hardened, then they’re ready to eat. It’s delicious!
It also wouldn’t be Christmas for me without saffron buns. Everyone in my family loves them and we usually start baking batches in early December. As they disappear very quickly (they’re great for breakfast!), I usually end up making several more batches. Last year was probably a record as I did it seven times! (40 buns each time … yes, that’s a lot of buns.) But the smell of the saffron as they bake really give the house that Christmas scent and I have to admit I also love eating the dough – very naughty but I can’t resist!
How about you – what sinfully delicious treats will you be indulging in during the festive season?










I don’t normally have much of a sweet tooth, but I love home made Christmas cookies. I’m not much of a baker myself, but my sister makes the best and shares. I’m also one of those people who actually likes fruit cake – especially if it has been soaking in brandy for a while. I usually just want a slice and then I stick it in the freezer and forget about it.
How lucky to have a sister who shares! I’m don’t usually eat many cookies either but I do like gingerbread ones at Christmas. There’s just something special about them! As for fruitcake – not for me I’m afraid but I’m glad you enjoy it!
I made a batch of caramel this weekend and yesterday I cut it into squares and dipped them in chocolate. I already gave some of it away but need to give more away so I don’t eat what’s left. 🙂 I do love homemade candy and festive cookies this time of year.
Happy holidays to you all.
Mmm sounds delicious Misti! It is lovely to give sweets away and they are always appreciated but do make sure you keep enough for yourself – it’s Christmas after all!
I don’t really bake but I love other people’s homemade goodies! I usually keep a big tin of Walker’s Shortbread in the house just in case. Who doesn’t love those?!
Oh yes, those are wonderful! I can eat shortbread any time 🙂
I love chocolate … all year round! Lemon brownies sound great to me; I’m used to chocolate and orange so why not lemon? Ooh, and I can’t recall the last time I ate pavlova (it might have been decades). Thank you all for this very drool worthy post!
Thanks Kareni, glad you enjoyed it! I’ve never tried lemon brownies but it does sound intriguing. And pavlova – yes, absolutely love it! I haven’t had that for ages so it might be time to make one soon.
Anne mentioned pavlova cake. Years ago I was in Australia and had this cake. It is so perfect at any time. If I could find it in NYC, I would have it in my refrigerator right now.
If I can find Boston Cream Pie, that will be perfect, too.
Chocolate cheese cake will do, too.
While I’m waiting for all the above, I am picking up my favorite cupcakes from Sprinkles, after I order them through the website, to make sure all are still available.
Patricia, you could always bake a pavlova. Here’s a foolproof recipe, and there’s even a video to show every step.
https://www.recipetineats.com/pavlova-recipe/
anne
Oooh cupcakes, yes please! Especially if they are of the chocolate variety. But all the treats you mentioned Patricia sound delicious!
Back in the day when I had my office pals to feed, I’d always do cookies, those being the only thing I knew how to make that travelled well. The chocolate chip cookies were easiest to do as all you have to do is put everything in the same bowl, stir it up and get it out again. I would also do peanut butter cookies as I enjoyed whacking them with the tenderizing hammer to get those little mountain shapes on the top. In those days many of my office mates were from foreign countries like Canada and the Philippines and they found these American style cookies quite exotic.
I am retired now and all those people have dispersed to wherever, and we’re all on diets and that, so I have given up baking. I miss it; it was fun.
I’m sure your coworkers appreciated your lovely cookies and miss them! Maybe you could make a batch for yourself and freeze some? I think cookies should freeze well. Then you can have some whenever you feel like it!
Biscuits, using my German grandmother’s recipes, which were from her mother, so probably least 100 years old. My mom & I have never managed to make the vast quantities she did, or the variety, so every year I have more respect for what she achieved.
How wonderful! I use my grandma’s recipes too and it’s lovely when traditions like that live on!
I probably won’t bake cookies this Christmas, but when I do, it’s often vanilla kipferl, aka Viennese almond crescents. They are delicate cookies made with ground almonds and dredged in vanilla sugar. I also love chocolate in any form and at any time!
Mmm, I love vanilla! It’s just such a wonderful flavour, isn’t it – love the sound of your cookies, Karin!
My sweet tooth goes crazy at thjs time of year! All things chocolate! All sorts of cakes candy and my favorite is a seven layer cake which if I am not careful i will scarf down the whole thing!> and rich hot chocolate and cookies of all sorts, my particular favorite is a small rainbow cookie which looks like a tiny layered cake..yum!i also love pfeferneuse(sp?) cookies and sugar cookies.
Wow that’s quite a selection, Jane! And it all sounds absolutely delicious – enjoy! That seven layer cake is intriguing, must be very rich 🙂
It doesn,t get any better than this…click on the link below to see a seven layer cake! I get mine at the local bakery, as well as the rainbow cookies…..
https://www.amazon.com/Dobosh-Scrumptious-Kosher-Sterns-Bakery/dp/B08619LTWW
Rainbow cookies image….
https://www.goldbelly.com/restaurants/carlos-bakery/rainbow-cookie-box-12-oz
Oh wow – looks amazing!
Ok – just reading these posts I have to unzip my jeans, cause they are now too tight.
Thanks for all the calories.
Y’all are wonderful to share so much with all of us.
LOL – thanks Annette, so glad you enjoyed our treats vicariously!
I never had much of a sweet tooth but at Christmas I do like gingerbread. I also like the crispy chocolate delight that Christina mentioned above. I used to make them for my kids when they were small. But whether I like these things or not, the delicious smell of baking them is wonderful at this time of year! Lovely post.
Thank you Teresa! Yes isn’t it wonderful when the whole house smells of baking and Christmas? I love that too.
In a nod to Pat, I often make lemon bars for Christmas, but another tradition in my family is to make Swedish Nuts. The recipe was handed down in our family over 60 years ago by an aunt-by-marriage who was of German ancestry. This treat consists of previously roasted almonds and walnuts, which are then folded into a meringue and then dropped onto a baking tray holding a melted stick of butter. The concoction is then baked, turning it over every 15 minutes until all of the butter is absorbed. After cooling, it is broken into pieces and stored in a tight container. The stuff is addictive! It also makes a wonderful hostess gift. I have no idea why they are called “Swedish Nuts.” Christina, could you shed any light on the subject?
That’s very intriguing Patricia! I’ve never heard of that although it sounds a bit like ‘knäckbräck’ – does it look anything like the picture in this recipe?
https://www.arla.se/recept/knackbrack/
If not I have no idea!
No, Swedish Nuts are nothing like knäbräck, which appears to be more like a “brittle.” The meringue in the recipe of Swedish Nuts, once baked, is a light tan color. I will send a picture to the website, as I made a fresh batch last evening.
Ok great – many thanks Patricia!